J. S. Bach: Suite No.6 for Cello Solo in D major, BWV 1012
Media Review / Comparison
2026-10-05 — Original posting.
Contents
- Introduction — The Recordings
- About the Suite No.6 for Cello Solo in D major, BWV 1012
- The Interpretations, Overview
- A Note on Ratings
- The Interpretations, Detail
- Procedure, Technical Aspects
- Pablo Casals, 1938
- Pierre Fournier, 1961
- Anner Bylsma, 1979
- Mstislav Rostropovich, 1991
- Anner Bylsma, 1992
- Jaap ter Linden, 1996
- Vito Paternoster, 1998
- Pieter Wispelwey, 1998
- Paolo Pandolfo, 2000 — Viola da gamba
- Steven Isserlis, 2005
- Jean-Guihen Queyras, 2007
- Ophélie Gaillard, 2010
- Pieter Wispelwey, 2012
- Isang Enders, 2013
- David Watkin, 2013
- Thomas Demenga, 2014
- Marianne Dumas, 2016
- Kim Kashkashian, 2017 — Viola
- Sergey Malov, 2018 — Violoncello da spalla
- Emmanuelle Bertrand, 2019
- Juris Teichmanis, 2019
- Benedict Kloeckner, 2020
- Myriam Rignol, 2020 — Viola da gamba
- Petr Skalka, 2020
- Lucile Boulanger, 2020— Viola da gamba (Partial)
- Bruno Philippe, 2021
- Pablo de Naverán, 2021
- Jean-Guihen Queyras, 2023
- Anastasia Kobekina, 2025
- Conclusions
- Other Review Posts on J.S. Bach’s Cello Suites, BWV 1007 – 1012
Introduction — The Recordings
This posting is about the Suite No.6 for Cello Solo in D major, BWV 1012, which Johann Sebastian Bach (1685 – 1750) wrote as part of a set of six Suites (see the title page above). I am comparing the following recordings in my collection:
| Recording | FirstName | LastName | Born | Death | Wiki | Web | Pitch Hz | Review | Summary |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2019 | Emmanuelle | Bertrand | 1973 | Wiki | a’ = 415 | Review | Artist, Media | ||
| 2020 | Lucile | Boulanger | 1986 | Wiki | Web | a’ = 415 | Review | Artist, Media | |
| 1979 | Anner | Bylsma | 1934 | 2019 | Wiki | a’ = 415 | Review | Artist, Media | |
| 1992 | Anner | Bylsma | 1934 | 2019 | Wiki | a’ = 432/415 | Review | Artist, Media | |
| 1936-39 | Pablo | Casals | 1876 | 1973 | Wiki | a’ = 440 | Review | Artist, Media | |
| 2014 | Thomas | Demenga | 1954 | Wiki | Web | a’ = 392 | Review | Artist, Media | |
| 2016 | Marianne | Dumas | 1978 | Web | a’ = 415 | Review | Artist, Media | ||
| 2013 | Isang | Enders | 1988 | Wiki | Web | a’ = 440 | Review | Artist, Media | |
| 1961 | Pierre | Fournier | 1906 | 1986 | Wiki | a’ = 440 | Review | Artist, Media | |
| 2010 | Ophélie | Gaillard | 1974 | Wiki | Web | a’ = 415 | Review | Artist, Media | |
| 2005 | Steven | Isserlis | 1958 | Wiki | Web | a’ = 440 | Review | Artist, Media | |
| 2017 | Kim | Kashkashian | 1952 | Wiki | Web | a’ = 440 | Review | Artist, Media | |
| 2020 | Benedict | Kloeckner | 1989 | Wiki | Web | a’ = 440 | Review | Artist, Media | |
| 2025 | Anastasia | Kobekina | 1994 | Wiki | Web | a’ = 415 | Review | Artist, Media | |
| 1996 | Jaap, ter | Linden | 1947 | Wiki | Web | a’ = 415 | Review | Artist, Media | |
| 2018 | Sergey | Malov | 1983 | Wiki | Web | a’ = 440 | Review | Artist, Media | |
| 2021 | Pablo, de | Naverán | 1975 | Web | a’ = 440 | Review | Artist, Media | ||
| 2000 | Paolo | Pandolfo | 1964 | Wiki | Web | a’ = 415 | Review | Artist, Media | |
| 1998 | Vito | Paternoster | 1957 | Wiki | Web | a’ = 440 | Review | Artist, Media | |
| 2021 | Bruno | Philippe | 1993 | Web | a’ = 440 | Review | Artist, Media | ||
| 2007 | Jean-Guihen | Queyras | 1967 | Wiki | Web | a’ = 440 | Review | Artist, Media | |
| 2023 | Jean-Guihen | Queyras | 1967 | Wiki | Web | a’ = 440 | Review | Artist, Media | |
| 2020 | Myriam | Rignol | 1988 | Wiki | Web | a’ = 400 | Review | Artist, Media | |
| 1991 | Mstislav | Rostropovich | 1927 | 2007 | Wiki | a’ = 440 | Review | Artist, Media | |
| 2020 | Petr | Skalka | 1974 | Web | a’ = 415 | Review | Artist, Media | ||
| 2019 | Juris | Teichmanis | 1966 | Web | a’ = 400 | Review | Artist, Media | ||
| 2013 | David | Watkin | 1965 | 2025 | Web | a’ = 415 | Review | Artist, Media | |
| 1998 | Pieter | Wispelwey | 1962 | Wiki | Web | a’ = 415 | Review | Artist, Media | |
| 2012 | Pieter | Wispelwey | 1962 | Wiki | Web | a’ = 392 | Review | Artist, Media |
Explanations on the Table
- You can sort the table by any specific column (in ascending or descending order) by selecting the respective title field.
- The first field is the year when the respective recording was completed (not necessarily identical to the ℗ or © years).
- The birth year is not known for all artists.
- The fields “Wiki” and “Web” are links to the respective artist’s Wikipedia entry and/or personal Website.
- The highlighted column “Review” contains links to the respective entry in the comparison section (The Interpretations, Detail) below.
- The green column “Summary” contains links to the respective entry in the comparison summary, featuring detailed Media information, as well as notes on artist, instrument, recording, etc.
Media Information
Details about the media (CDs) are available as part of the Comparison Summary on Bach’s Suites for Cello Solo. That information includes cover image, title, artists, technical media information (label, label-number, booklet info, barcode, amazon link, where available, plus additional information, as deemed relevant). That summary also features an overall comparison table.
About the Suite No.6 for Cello Solo in D major, BWV 1012
I don’t need to give a detailed introduction to Bach’s six Suites for Cello Solo, as they are all well-known. However, you do find some additional information on the Suite No.6 for Cello Solo in D major, BWV 1012 in reviews on concerts featuring the entire Suite No.6:
- 2020-06-28, artist: Chiara Enderle Samatanga (*1992) — Suite No.3 in C major, BWV 1009; Suite No.6 in D major, BWV 1012; Suite No.1 in G major, BWV 1007 (Prélude, as encore)
- 2021-04-25, artist: Anastasia Kobekina (*1994, see also Wikipedia) — The complete 6 Suites for Cello Solo, BWV 1007 – 1012
Partial performances:
- On 2018-05-31, in a pre-concert, Chiara Enderle Samatanga performed three movements (Prélude, Allemande, Gigue) from Suite No.6
What’s Special About the Suite No.6 in D major?
Bach wrote his Cello Suites in ascending order of technical and musical difficulty. The Suite No.1 in G major is popular and easy to understand, while Suite No.4 in E♭ major features technical challenges from an inconvenient key and playing intricacies. The Suite No.5 in C minor features scordatura, which presents mental challenges when reading and playing, in addition to being musically demanding.
Suite No.6 in D major avoids both awkward keys and scordatura complications. Its extraordinary tonal range, reaching up to b”, is what makes this suite unique. Consequently, Bach uses not only the bass clef (F, 𝄢), but also the alto clef (𝄡 on the middle line) and occasionally the soprano clef (𝄡 on the bottom line). Indeed, the suite is written for an instrument with an extra string for a total of five, tuned C – G – d – a – e’, as indicated above the Prélude. This was most likely a five-string violoncello piccolo.
Instruments Used to Perform and Record This Suite
There are no chords involving five strings, so from a purely technical point-of-view, the suite can be performed on a four-string instrument, even though it will involve reaching up to the part of the strings beyond the fingerboard, typically covered with white rosin dust (often referred to as “eternal snow”). Indeed, traditional (definitely non-HIP) performances use a standard, modern cello with four strings, tuned to C – G – d – a, or a modernized historical instrument: most baroque instruments have been modernized to accommodate the needs for today’s larger concert venues and an extended tonal range. This means changing to a steeper and typically longer neck (higher string tension) and a longer fingerboard.
“Proper” historical four-string cellos that have not been modernized are not ideal for this suite because of their shorter fingerboards. Therefore, many of the recent HIP recordings use a historical or reconstructed five-string violoncello piccolo. Of the recordings included in this comparison, the majority (15) use a regular, four-string instrument, and 11 use a five-string instrument, as specified in the original source. The latter is either a violoncello piccolo, a violoncello da spalla as used by Sergey Malov, or a viola in the case of Kim Kashkashian.
Three of the recordings use a seven-string viola da gamba. This instrument has a unique string configuration and a fretted fingerboard. It requires an underhand bow hold. These features imply a completely different playing technique, setting these performances apart and placing them in a class of their own.
The Movements
Bach completed his Six Suites for Violoncello Solo senza Basso, BWV 1007 – 1012 (6 Suites a Violoncello Solo senza Basso) around 1717 – 1723 in Köthen (Anhalt), presumably for himself, for the purpose of learning to play the instrument. From the first Suite up to No.6, the technical demands of these compositions grow. For cellists all over the world, this is considered the “Bible” of their repertoire.
Bach’s original manuscript appears to be lost. However, there is a beautiful manuscript, now identified as being a copy that Bach’s second wife Anna Magdalena Bach (1701 – 1760) created around 1727 – 1731. The facsimile of Anna Magdalena’s copy can now be downloaded from IMSLP.
In lieu of explanations on the individual movements, I’m just including short excerpts from that document, showing the first 2 – 3 lines of each movement.
I. Prélude
The Prélude is one of the few movements with dynamic annotations indicating that, the second instance of the repeated bars should be played as an echo (“p.” and “f.” or, in some sources, “piano” and “forte” explicitly). One of the 18th century sources, the manuscript copy by Johann Peter Kellner (1705 – 1772), lacks the dynamic annotations entirely (Eppstein, 1988).
A notable feature of the Prélude in this suite is that the placement of the slurs in the early sources is, at best, superficial and inconsequential, as can be seen in the above excerpt. The neat image presented by modern editions is the result of inference and guesswork.
In the first two bars (and subsequent equivalent instances), Bach uses bariolage: in quaver triplets, the first two (or all three) notes are at the same pitch, but the middle note (tied to the first one) is played on the adjacent string. This is indicated by downward stems on the outer notes and an upward stem on the middle note. This notation is specifically used for bariolage motifs. Even when the first two notes are tied and at the same pitch, the bariolage technique causes them to retain their individual quality.
II. Allemande
The most prominent feature of this movement is the abundant and explicit ornamentation of the melody line, dominated by demisemiquavers, with note values as short as semihemidemisemiquavers (1/256th). Because of this, the movement’s 4/4 time signature (common time, C) is often difficult to perceive. The rich ornamentation leads some artists to ignore the time signature and select an extremely slow tempo. Conversely, artists who focus on the time signature must squeeze the ornaments into the limited time frame. Consequently, the tempo range across interpretations of this movement is extreme.
As usual, there are discrepancies between the various 18th-century sources. These aren’t limited to slurs and ties which are often inaccurate or missing, but also extend to the notes themselves. For example, in the second bar, where Anna Magdalena Bach’s manuscript copy lacks the chord notes on the second and third beats (b and b/e, respectively), as well as the trill on the last beat. These elements are all present in the other sources. In bar 2, few artists strictly follow Anna Magdalena Bach’s manuscript copy, among them Anner Bylsma (1979, first pass only, and 1992), Pierre Fournier (!), and Jean-Guihen Queyras (2007, first pass only). The other recordings use the “richer” version from the other sources.
III. Courante
One expects a Courante to have a dance-like sway and a certain fluidity in tempo. What that exactly means is left up to the artist. The recordings reveal a common issue in Bach’s Cello Suites: the slurring in Anna Magdalena Bach’s manuscript copy is often inaccurate and/or inconsequential. This can already be seen in the first two lines above. Other available 18th-century sources attempted to clarify and clean up the score but only added to the confusion.
IV. Sarabande
The Sarabande raises the ubiquitous question about the proper tempo. The Suites were conceived in the early 18th century. Is this Sarabande reminiscent of the fast dance that it once was in 16th- and 17th-century Spain? Or is it more reminiscent of the Sarabanda in 17th-century Italy? Or is it more akin to the slow dance it became in France in the late 17th century? In the context of Bach’s music, the latter is typically chosen. However, that still leaves a lot of room for interpretation. Unsurprisingly, the recordings in this comparison range from approximately ♩=35 up to ♩=60 (note that the movement is in 3/2 time).
However, after listening to the two slowest recordings of this movement (Pierre Fournier and Pieter Wispelwey 1998) I concluded that the choice of tempo for this movement is secondary. What matters much more is what the artists make of this music and what they can evoke in the listener’s mind and soul.
V. Gavotte I
The first Gavotte has the form (A)-(BA), with repeat signs around both parts. Anna Magdalena Bach’s manuscript copy is rather sketchy regarding the placement and positioning of slurs. Gavotte I is in split time (alla breve, ₵). Gavotte I makes a second appearance as a da capo, typically without repeats. The main challenge of this piece is incorporating the three- and four-string chords into the musical flow.
VI. Gavotte II
The second Gavotte is in rondo form, i.e., (A)-(BACA), again with repeat signs around both parts. The movement is in two voices. The second part consists of two couplets (B and C) and two instances of the ritornello. The first couplet features an ostinato accompaniment in the lower voice. In the “C” section, the lower voice is a drone on d, creating a lovely musette effect, derived from bagpipe music. Gavotte II has a time signature of “2”, which was traditionally used in France for a meter with bars of two half notes (or four crotchets). Technically, this is synonymous with split time.
VII. Gigue
The Gigue, literally the final dance of all of Bach’s Cello Suites, is more than just a joyful, possibly fun last movement. It presents numerous technical challenges. Bach may have conceived it as the Suite’s technical culmination. One such challenge is incorporating arpeggio chords into the musical flow while maintaining the dance-like character of the piece. This challenge is similar to the one in the first Gavotte. Additionally, there are numerous large jumps over several strings that further disrupt the continuity of the musical flow and the dance-like quality.
Anna Magdalena Bach’s digitized manuscript copy is available from the Staatsbibliothek zu Berlin, Preußischer Kulturbesitz. This document is in the public domain and shared under a Creative Commons (CC-BY 4.0) International License. It is free of known restrictions under copyright law, including all related and neighboring rights.
The Interpretations, Overview
To provide a rating overview, as well as an idea about duration relations between the recordings, I have prepared the table below. Note that the color coding for the duration (blue = longer/slower, red = shorter/faster) refers to the average between the recordings.

I have not corrected the timings for trailing or leading blank time, with the one exception of the first and last movements, where such blank time is subtracted. One should read the timings in the above table with a grain of salt.
Repeats
Not all artists perform all repeats. In the cases where repeats were omitted, the track durations were corrected in the table, by adding the time for the missing repeats to the track duration. In that sense, the durations in the table are to be read as “if the artist had performed all repeats“. For the actual track and overall durations please see the section below. These may differ from the numbers in liner notes: I’m ripping the recording into Apple Music and use the times in the player software, which may use different rounding algorithms.
A Note on Ratings
First and foremost: all my ratings reflect my own opinion, hence are inherently subjective. I use a 1 – 5-star rating scheme—simply because that’s what my player software (Apple Music) offers. I use the same scheme for concert reviews. You will note that for these, there are rarely reviews below a 3.0 (★★★) rating. That’s largely because I try to avoid concerts where I anticipate a marginal performance. And I stick to an “absolute” scale, where results below 3.0 are negative.
Ratings in Media Comparisons
In media comparisons, especially reviews involving many recordings, I tend to use a relative scale covering the full range of (close to) ★ … ★★★★★, to achieve more differentiation among the many ratings. My rating criteria resemble the ones in concert, such as
- does the performance reflect the notation, i.e., the composer’s (perceived) intent?
- does it present the character of the piece (e.g., in the dance movements in baroque suites)?
Personal Views
My ratings also reflect how much a recording offers to me, particularly as a listener with interest in historically informed (HIP) performances. With this, I tend to give preference to HIP recordings. I do not mean to devalue the achievements of historic recordings by the great artists of the last century. However, time has moved on, and it is my belief that the in-depth encounter with HIP performances makes it hard(er) to enjoy some of the traditional recordings, especially romantic ones with heavy vibrato, etc. Again: this is my personal view, and I don’t mean to spoil the pleasure that the fans of past great cellists (or of polished, “modern” interpretations) draw from their recordings.
Audiophile?
I should also mention that audiophile arguments play a secondary role in my ratings. My primary focus is on the interpretation, not perfection in recording technique. The latter comes into play mainly where it affects the audibility, clarity, and transparency, e.g., through excess reverberation. And for newer recordings, blatantly dull, “muffled” sound should also influence the rating.
The Interpretations, Detail
The review comments below are sorted by recording year, from the oldest (1936 – 1939) to the most recent one (2021). Note: for the artist’s life data, Website and/or Wikipedia entries please see the first table above. Also: in the artist segments below, the pitch is mentioned only where it deviates from a’ = 440 Hz.
Procedure, Technical Aspects
I listen to all recordings in full, typically even more than once. Note that the sequence of recordings below is not the sequence in which I listen to them. I have written about my comparison approach in an early blog post. In essence:
- I go through the collection movement by movement, i.e., I start with listening to the first movement with all recordings before progressing to the next movement.
- I try to choose a sequence that does not put subsequent recordings at a disadvantage. Typically, I start with slow performances, progressing to faster ones. At the same time, I try using a suitable sequence of historic vs. “conventional” vs. HIP interpretations.
- Especially in large comparisons, such as this one, the sequence will typically vary from movement to movement.
- In the sequence in which I listen to the tracks, I typically “just” move forward. If I relate to other interpretations, I refer to recordings I listened to previously, irrespective of the time of the recording. In other words: for older recordings I may use comparisons to interpretations of artists who may not even have been alive at the time of the early version. That may occasionally sound strange. However, in the interest of efficiency, I can’t risk “jumping around” to amend comments that I have already written.
- Naturally, my comments will mostly refer to the recordings immediately preceding the one I’m writing about—in the listening sequence for that given movement (it is impossible to memorize all performances in detail). However, I try my very best to make the ratings absolute, not relative.
- The change in listening sequence from one movement to the next provides the added benefit of not always comparing or contrasting any given performance with the same “competing” interpretation.
Duplications…
It’s been a while since my last review in this series. I try not to delay these reviews too much. However, the delay has the advantage that I can approach this review without bias from the preceding ones. I apologize for duplication with earlier reviews. One benefit of the text duplications is that they help making each review readable by itself, minimizing the need to follow cross-links to other postings.
Pablo Casals, 1938
EMI Classics, ℗ 1988/2003 / © 2003
Artist: Pablo Casals (1876 – 1973)
Instrument: Mattio Goffriller (1659 – 1742), Venice, 1700
See the Comparison Summary for more information on artist, instrument, recording location etc.
For general comments concerning recording quality and settings, acoustics, as well as the artist’s approach to the Cello Suites see the posting on the Suite No.1 for Cello Solo in G major, BWV 1007. Pablo Casals’ cello is a standard, modernized four-string instrument.
I. Prélude (5’07”)
The timing indicates a Prélude performance that is slightly faster than Mstislav Rostropovich’s. However, the two performances are hardly comparable. Casals’ performance opens a tad slower than Rostropovich’s. Casals’ timing shorter due to the artist’s use of tempo variations (one might even call it rubato) as a means of expression. Of course, the idea of Klangrede (Harnoncourt, 1983) hadn’t emerged at the time of Casals’ recording, so dynamics, tempo variations and phrasing were more important than detailed articulation at the level of motifs.
Compared to Rostropovich’s recording, Casals’ sounds very different. This difference is not due to the older, simpler recording technique. Rather, it stems from Casals’ unwavering engagement and intensity. Unlike Rostropovich, Casals doesn’t apply energy evenly and persistently to the entire melodic line. Instead, he uses subtle tempo variations (see above) and broadening of key notes to shape phrases. Casals’ dynamic sculpting of phrases is also much more nuanced than Rostropovich’s. This results in a richer overall experience, from the first notes to the gentle diminuendo in the final bars.
II. Allemande (7’31”)
Casals’ tempo in the Allemande is above average. Nevertheless, the performance sounds extraordinarily intense, thoughtful and reflective. This is partly due to the artist’s dense tone and intense vibrato. However, the key point about this interpretation is that Casals ignores the 4/4 (C) time signature. Instead, he plays the piece in quavers, treating Bach’s built-in ornamentation as melodic phrases.
No detail in the small notes is lost, and every note has expressive value, to the effect that each of the two parts appears as one single, very long phrase that never drops the tension. Compared to recent interpretations, the performance lacks Klangrede, as well as dynamic contrast and bandwidth.
There are also peculiarities in the interpretation, such as the omission of the ties in bars 1, 2, and 9, as well as Casals’ treatment of trills. Nowadays, Baroque trills predominantly start on the upper (alternate) note, unless the alternate note immediately precedes the trill. Bach does not use acciaccaturas to indicate starting on the alternate (upper) note. One could conclude that this leaves this decision up to the artist. However, some of Casals’ trills may still appear slightly unusual.
III. Courante (3’43”)
For its age, this performance is absolutely amazing and still easily surpasses many others, including Pierre Fournier’s 1961 recording. Although Casals’ articulation has some peculiarities, none of them sound idiosyncratic. Some of the high passages on the a string stand out prominently. However, this can easily be attributed to the early recording technique. Not all deficiencies can be corrected or evened out in the restoration of early cello recordings. Maintaining authenticity is far more important.
IV. Sarabande (4’18”)
Within this comparison, Pablo Casals’ interpretation of the Sarabande is among the faster performances. However, it would be neither fair nor appropriate to compare this historic performance with more recent traditional recordings. Casals, of course, used his signature tone, complete with intense, permanent vibrato and broad yet percussive articulation. He uses a tempo that is adequate for a slow movement in 3/2 time, and the rhythmic swaying follows the meter of the movement. Today’s renditions of the Sarabande feel entirely different. Undoubtedly, though, this is not just a historic document; this performance is superior to the traditional recordings by Pierre Fournier and Mstislav Rostropovich.
V./VI. Gavotte I — Gavotte II — Gavotte I da capo (3’04”)
Gavotte I
In many newer interpretations (both HIP and non-HIP) the arpeggio chords seem difficult to perform. They often require extra time, causing delays and disrupting the rhythmic flow. After listening to such interpretations, turning to Casals feels like a revelation. With Casals, the chords don’t take much, if any, extra time. He plays them with so much energy and verve that each arpeggio seems to add momentum, propelling the performance forward. It’s marvelous! While the timing indicates a relatively fast performance, the actual pace isn’t all that fast, but the artist doesn’t spend extra time on the chords.
In this Gavotte, Casals does not play the second repeat. He probably felt that, together with the da capo, Gavotte I is played twice already, even without repeats. By omitting the longer repeat, there is more of a balance between the two sister movements.
Gavotte II
In the ritornello, the second Gavotte connects very much with Gavotte I, even though it is gentler, more tamed, and less impulsive. The crotchet sequences feature a percussive staccato, but are never harsh. The two couplets, however, create beautiful contrasts. They offer an intimate, warm atmosphere. The first is cozy and relaxed, while the second, a musette, is more folksy and pastoral. Masterful!
VII. Gigue (3’59”)
What a powerful performance! It is still engraved in my memory from my first encounter with this music 56 years ago, when I received an LP of Casals playing Suites No.5 & 6. I even clearly remember the spontaneous, brief groaning noise the artist makes in the repeat, toward the end of bar 15. Casals’ playing is energetic throughout, and his drive remains unperturbed by the eruptive arpeggio chords. Rather, these propel the performance forward, and throughout the movement, there is a persistent dance sway. Nothing is ever static or rigid in this enthralling interpretation. Sure, upon closer inspection, one may find notes with imperfect intonation, but these don’t affect the overall impression: it’s the artist’s musicality which counts. Keep in mind that at the time of the recording, the only way to correct imperfections was to re-record an entire movement.
Total Duration: 27’42”
Rating: 3.5 / 3.5 / 4 / 4 / 5 / 5 / 5 = 4.29
Comment: Pablo Casals’ recording is more than just an invaluable historical document. It is an essential resource for cellists studying Bach’s Cello Suites, as well as for serious collectors of his solo works.
Pierre Fournier, 1961
Archiv Produktion / Polydor International, ℗ 1961
Artist: Pierre Fournier (1906 – 1986)
Instrument: Charles Adolphe Maucotel (c.1820 – c.1858), Paris, 1849
See the Comparison Summary for more information on artist, instrument, recording location etc.
For general comments concerning recording quality and settings, acoustics, as well as the artist’s approach to the Cello Suites see the posting on the Suite No.1 for Cello Solo in G major, BWV 1007. Pierre Fournier’s cello is a standard, modernized four-string instrument.
I. Prélude (5’01”)
As expected, listeners find Pierre Fournier’s beautiful, well-balanced sonority from the bass to the highest descant. The tempo is similar to Pablo Casals’ and other interpretations that approach the Prélude at a moderate pace. However, that does not preclude the impression of an interpretation that has completely “fallen out of our time”. Even ignoring HIP performances, this interpretation is as far from what we understand as baroque playing practice as it can get. To me, the interpretation misses the character of Bach’s composition.
The bariolage bars alone raise questions. Throughout the movement, it is difficult to discern whether Fournier observes the slurs and ties. Instead, it sounds as if every quaver has its own, little accent. The result is not a movement in 12/8 time; it actually feels like a fast, springy Gigue in 3/8 time, in which the bariolage notation appears pointless. Additionally, Bach’s p and f annotations are often mere allusions. This is one of the few instances in which Bach uses dynamic markings. Shouldn’t these be shown more prominently?
Finally, even though every note has elasticity and intensity, the interpretation feels relentless. It lacks even traces of agogics supporting the phrasing—a relic from a time when Bach’s music was seen as “constantly flowing”?
II. Allemande (5’43”)
Unsurprisingly, Fournier celebrates this movement with broad legato articulation and a permanent, intense vibrato. Traditionalists may praise his beautiful tone and sonority. However, the artist is reading the ornamentation literally, without rhythmic flexibility, and very metrically and straight. The listener is overwhelmed by the ornamentation and cannot perceive any defined meter or sensible phrasing. It’s an interpretation from a different era. It has fallen out of our time. In view of this, the omission of the second repeat is a minor deficiency.
It comes as a surprise that in bar 2, Fournier doesn’t use the “richer” version that most artists refer to, but strictly adheres to Anna Magdalena Bach’s manuscript copy (see above).
III. Courante (3’49”)
Fournier’s articulation of the quavers is peculiar. Toward the end of a motif and for notes that he wants to highlight, he typically changes from staccato or spiccato to broad tenuto or legato. This happens so predictably that it becomes an idiosyncrasy. There is very little, agogics, and with the accents on the first beat in most bars or motifs, the interpretation feels rather rigid and schematic, despite the fluid tempo. Oddly, there are semiquaver passages in which the intonation is superficial.
IV. Sarabande (3’47”)
One could call this interpretation an epic misunderstanding or an overly romantic reading of Bach’s Sarabande. It is the slowest performance of the piece. The slowness is exacerbated by Fournier’s permanent quasi-legato playing. He “pulls” every note with constant intensity for as long as possible. The only notes that aren’t played at full length are the low notes in three- and four-string chords, which, for obvious reasons, cannot be held. The primary argument against this interpretation is that it is unthinkable to hold such long notes with gut strings and the shorter baroque bow. Therefore, the interpretation is beyond what Bach might have envisioned.
Apart from the above arguments against this interpretation, the endless stretching of all notes makes melodic elements unrecognizable and makes it difficult or impossible to sense the rhythm (meter) or to perceive any larger rhythmic and harmonic progressions and structures. The only “saving grace” is that Fournier saves us from the repeat of the longer second part. To me, this feels more like a curiosity than a serious interpretation of this piece. The only “saving grace” is that the artist saves us from the repeat of the much longer second part. The repeat of the first part appears identical to the first pass: no ornaments added, just softer in volume.
V./VI. Gavotte I — Gavotte II — Gavotte I da capo (4’38”)
Gavotte I
Fournier plays with utmost firmness, rigidity, and determination, devoid of elegance, lightness, playfulness, or even traces of a dance spirit.
Gavotte II
In contrast, the second Gavotte is much more pleasant. It is soft, gentle, harmonious, and almost introverted—a nice contrast to the first Gavotte. Only the broad détaché on the crotchets feel a bit odd, naïve, and old-fashioned.
VII. Gigue (4’05”)
Fournier plays with firm, percussive articulation. His sonority is full, characterful, and slightly grainy, supported by his ubiquitous vibrato. In détaché quavers, he switches between decisive staccato and springy legato, where one can almost sense an underlying semiquaver pace. His arpeggio chords are energetic and often eruptive. It’s characterful, but definitely far from HIP.
Total Duration: 27’03”
Rating: 2.5 / 2.5 / 2.5 / 2.5 / 2.5 / 3 / 3 = 2.64
Comment: As expected, Fournier remains true to his style, offering a traditional interpretation that is typical of the mid-20th century. I can only recommend this as a historical document, as it has very little to do with how we understand Baroque music today. It should certainly not be the only recording in a collection.
Anner Bylsma, 1979
Sony / Essential Classics, ℗ 1979 / © 1999
Artist: Anner Bylsma (1934 – 2019)
Instrument: Five-string violoncello piccolo (South Tyrol, c.1700); baroque bow
Pitch: a’ = 415 Hz
See the Comparison Summary for more information on artist, instrument, recording location etc.
For general comments concerning recording quality and settings, acoustics, as well as the artist’s approach to the Cello Suites see the posting on the Suite No.1 for Cello Solo in G major, BWV 1007.
I. Prélude (4’41”)
In his first interpretation, Anner Bylsma’s tempo for the Prélude is exactly average among the recordings in this comparison. This is a pioneering historically informed (HIP) performance: sonority and articulation are exemplary, though the interpretation often appears rhythmically static and slightly rigid, focusing too much on four beats per bar and lacking agogics. The semiquaver cadenza is an exception, retaining exceptional clarity despite its virtuosic tempo. The virtuosity is highlighted by the détaché articulation in the ascending figures in bars 85 and 86.
Naturally, the artist has no problem playing the high passages on a five-string instrument, though the highest range often has a flageolet-like tonal quality. The intonation of some of the chords in bars 98 and 99 is not slightly imperfect.
II. Allemande (6’59”)
In this pioneering recording, Anner Bylsma was not primarily concerned with a clean, polished performance, or smooth sonority. Instead, he aimed for historical authenticity based on available sources. His first recording of the D major Suite features one of the fastest performances of the Allemande. In the context of this comparison, the interpretation may initially feel unusually fluid in the ornamented voice. However, listeners quickly adjust to this performance. In fact, it is one of the few interpretations that don’t celebrate the ornaments. More importantly it makes the listener feel a true 4/4 dance sway.
In the first pass, Bylsma uses the simpler version of bar 2 from Anna Magdalena Bach’s manuscript copy (see above). In the repeat, he switches to the “richer” version from the other 18th-century sources.
III. Courante (3’37”)
Anner Bylsma’s first recording features light, clean, and fluid playing. However, it is a tad schematic, lacking flexibility, breathing, and agogics. It is difficult to sense a persistent dance swaying.
IV. Sarabande (4’06”)
Based on its timing, Anner Bylsma’s 1979 recording of the Sarabande is one of the fastest in this comparison. However, it does not sound “fast” at all. Bylsma strictly adheres to the 3/2 meter, making this performance feel like a solemn, stately dance. Overall, though, the heavy accent on every half-note beat feels a bit too systematic. As a result, the piece becomes a formal dance with little expression or emotion. While the interpretation is impressive in its consistency, from the perspective of recent HIP performances, one would wish for more lyricism, agogics, and expression.
V./VI. Gavotte I — Gavotte II — Gavotte I da capo (3’01”)
Gavotte I
Of all the recordings in this comparison, Bylsma’s first Gavotte is the fastest. Only Jean-Guihen Queyras’ 2007 recording comes close in tempo. The articulation is careful, though slightly terse. The rhythmic accents of the arpeggio chords do not hinder the musical flow. Rather, the performance feels somewhat driven. However, it lacks agogics and dynamic differentiation, as well as Klangrede (Harnoncourt, 1983).
Gavotte II
The second Gavotte is similar in tempo and articulation. Also this movement is among the fastest in the comparison, though this time, Jean-Guihen Queyras’ 2007 recording beats it by a fair margin. The artist’s 1992 recording is preferable, as it suffers less from the frequently whirring e’ string. Unfortunately, Bylsma omitted the second repeat in this recording, depriving the listeners of the opportunity to re-listen to the two folksy couplets.
VII. Gigue (3’36”)
Alongside Sergey Malov’s recording (on a violoncello da spalla), Anner Bylsma’s 1979 recording is the fastest performance in this comparison. Compared to the other recordings, it feels very fluid. However, it is not rushed and remains controlled from beginning to end. The clarity and detail of its articulation are exemplary. The performance remains virtuosic and enthralling throughout—a true final dance! That said, the recording leaves the listener somewhat breathless. It would be nice to have time to breathe between phrases.
Total Duration: 26’01”
Rating: 3.5 / 4.5 / 3.5 / 4 / 3.5 / 3.5 / 4.5 = 3.86
Comment: While it cannot compete with many more recent HIP recordings, this recording is still a valuable testimony, a landmark from the early phases of historically informed performance practice. It’s interesting and recommended, though you may want to cross-check Anner Bylsma’s newer 1992 recording.
Mstislav Rostropovich, 1991
EMI Classics, ℗/© 1995
Artist: Mstislav Rostropovich (1926 – 2007)
Instrument: Cello “Duport” by Antonio Stradivari (1644 – 1737), Cremona, 1711
See the Comparison Summary for more information on artist, instrument, recording location etc.
For general comments concerning recording quality and settings, acoustics, as well as the artist’s approach to the Cello Suites see the posting on the Suite No.1 for Cello Solo in G major, BWV 1007. Mstislav Rostropovich’s cello is a standard, modernized four-string instrument.
I. Prélude (5’17”)
Though it’s not really slow, the timing of this track indicates the slowest performance in this movement. The tempo feels normal and considerate. The artist observes Bach’s dynamic annotations, so the performance is dynamically structured. Sadly, however, Rostropovich plays with virtually no agogics, with persistent intensity, using permanent tenuto, if not quasi-legato articulation. This gives the impression of relentlessness. Still, there is a persistent buildup towards a fermata on the dotted crotchet in bar 83, at the beginning of the cadenza section dominated by virtuosic semiquaver figures. The wavy motion in bars 85 and 86 is performed with spiccato, if not sautillé articulation, which can hardly have been Bach’s intent. Finally: the intonation is not flawless. At times, it even feels careless.
II. Allemande (10’31”)
Not only is this the slowest of the Allemande performances, it’s also a total disaster. The excessive use of vibrato is the least of the problems. Indeed, the tempo is so slow that the underlying melodic and harmonic foundation is lost to the listener. Rostropovich is crawling through the piece so slowly that the built-in ornamentation (semiquavers, demisemiquavers, etc.) appears as melody elements. Given the nature of ornamentation, these melody fragments are devoid of structural function. It’s an endless, abject meandering tapeworm.
III. Courante (3’32”)
I wish Rostropovich had had even a basic understanding of Bach’s music. His performance sounds loud, coarse, and rigid. It progresses like a steamroller and moves like an elephant in a china shop. Sure, the performance is virtuosic, and there is dynamic differentiation, but there is not even a trace of agogics, and the staccato is rigid.
IV. Sarabande (4’52”)
I need to watch my language here, even though Rostropovich’s interpretation did not come as a surprise. Although this performance has the same timing as Benedikt Kloeckner’s recording, it feels like its antithesis. Where Kloeckner uses carefully controlled, even gentle dynamics, Rostropovich plays ff in broad tenuto strokes almost throughout. The only exceptions are bars 17 – 22 and 25 – 27, where he temporarily reduces the volume to p. However, he quickly returns to ff with excessive, permanent, and dominant vibrato. Is this an attempt to build a cathedral from Bach’s warm and intimate movement? The attempt is futile, the performance misses the point entirely. Even the intonation isn’t always clean.
V. Gavotte I — (2’17”)
In short: Rostropovich’s interpretation of the first Gavotte is slow, clumsy, heavy, schematic, stomping, loud, and “square”. It lacks agogics and differentiation in dynamics and articulation. This is not the folk dance that it’s meant to be.
VI. Gavotte II — Gavotte I da capo (2’54”)
Compared to Gavotte I, the second Gavotte is played at a much more acceptable tempo and with more differentiated dynamics. One can even sense a slight, dance-like sway.
VII. Gigue (4’09”)
I’m sorry, but this performance is abominable. Most notably, the intonation is careless and often beyond the pale. The articulation is also negligent, especially in the rather mechanical détaché quavers. The artist plows through the piece with little to no agogics.
Total Duration: 33’32”
Rating: 2 / 2 / 2.5 / 2 / 2 / 2.5 / 2 = 2.14
Comment: As I’ve said before, Rostropovich should not have recorded Bach. He did a huge disservice to his legacy.
Anner Bylsma, 1992
Sony Classical, ℗/© 1992
Artist: Anner Bylsma (1934 – 2019)
Instrument: Five-string violoncello piccolo (South Tyrol, c.1700); baroque bow
Pitch: a’ = 415 Hz
See the Comparison Summary for more information on artist, instrument, recording location etc.
For general comments concerning recording quality and settings, acoustics, as well as the artist’s approach to the Cello Suites see the posting on the Suite No.1 for Cello Solo in G major, BWV 1007.
I. Prélude (4’29”)
Compared to his somewhat static 1979 recording, Anner Bylsma switched to a notably more fluid pace. In fact, the pace of his interpretation occasionally feels slightly pushed. Relative to the lower strings, the e’ string retains the flute- or flageolet-like sonority that the first recording also exhibited. The semiquaver cadenza is astounding in its virtuosity: despite the faster pace, Bylsma retains the détaché articulation throughout bars 85 and 86, as if Bach conceived this movement as a virtuosic showpiece.
Finally, I don’t understand why Bylsma plays broken chords with the top note lagging behind in bars 98 and 99; in his first recording on the same five-string instrument, these chords appeared as effortless, natural arpeggios. Therefore, the instrument is clearly compatible with three-string arpeggios. Nevertheless, this newer recording is clearly superior to the 1979 one.
II. Allemande (8’28”)
For his second recording, Anner Bylsma rethought his interpretation of the D major Suite. In some movements, he kept almost the same tempo as in his 1979 recording. In other movements, such as the Allemande, he switched from one of the fastest tempos to a very moderate pace. His 1992 tempo is slightly faster than Lucile Boulanger’s (viola da gamba) and very close to Pieter Wispelwey’s in his 1998 recording.
The listening experience is that of a rather slow interpretation. Lucile Boulanger and David Watkin demonstrated that an even slower pace can work in this movement. Even though he handles the meter with some flexibility, Bylsma takes Bach’s ornamentation too literally. In comparison to newer HIP performances, his interpretation lacks agogics and expression at the level of motifs. The ornaments should be much more flexible to breathe life into the interpretation. Overall, it’s slightly disappointing.
Unlike his 1979 recording, Bylsma now consistently uses the simpler version of bar 2 from Anna Magdalena Bach’s manuscript copy.
III. Courante (3’39”)
In his second recording, Anner Bylsma has maintained the same timing as his 1979 recording. However, his playing is less strict and more expressive. The articulation is more detailed and diverse. The big phrases now breathe, though not as much as in recent HIP recordings. On the other hand, the second interpretation is less controlled and focuses less on clean playing and aesthetics. The articulation sometimes feels spontaneous and is not always consistent, with the occasional whirring of strings.
In bar 67 of his 1997 performance, Anner Bylsma is one of very few artists who follows Anna Magdalena Bach’s manuscript copy, where the central motif features two quavers G-E rather than the semiquaver figure adopted by the other 18th-century sources and the Neue Bach-Ausgabe (Eppstein, 1988).
IV. Sarabande (4’20”)
In his 1992 recording, Anner Bylsma “reinvented” his interpretation of the Sarabande. Among the artists with two recordings in this comparison, I can’t think of another example where the artist turned his interpretation upside down so completely. The other artists are Pieter Wispelwey (1998 and 2012) and Jean-Guihen Queyras (2007 and 2023).
Thirteen years after his 1979 recording, Bylsma switched to a noticeably slower pace and moved away from a rigid, heavily pounding 3/2 rhythm. The articulation is now almost mellow, often with a subtle, harmoniously swaying vibrato. The interpretation breathes in gentle dynamic waves while still exhibiting the 3/2 meter. Every phrase tells a story. In this recording of Suite No.6, this is the best movement yet, beautiful, serene, and reflective.
V./VI. Gavotte I — Gavotte II — Gavotte I da capo (3’47”)
Gavotte I
After his fast performance in the 1979 recording of the first Gavotte, Anner Bylsma opted for a moderate tempo in the 1992 recording. The pace is now slightly below average in this comparison. Even though articulating three- and four-string arpeggios takes its time, the artist is able to maintain rhythmic continuity and a slight sense of dance.
Gavotte II
The second Gavotte is softer and does not exaggerate the folksy aspects of the piece. In the first couplet, Bylsma focuses on the melody (upper voice), making the lower ostinato voice mere accompaniment. The second couplet (musette) is slightly faster. In this interpretation, the drone pulsates rather than being almost continuous, as in other recordings. This diminishes some of the musette character. It’s a pity the second repeat is omitted.
VII. Gigue (3’47”)
Thirteen years after his 1979 recording, Anner Bylsma’s interpretation has lost some of its bite. The tempo is still among the fastest, but it feels a tad more relaxed. Overall, though, it remains somewhat breathless. The articulation is just as clear and detailed, though occasionally slightly softer. The instrument and bow are the same, yet, the recording sounds brighter. In the descant especially, the tone has a distinct, slightly pungent singing quality. The dynamics are somewhat more differentiated, but I still prefer the 1979 recording overall.
Total Duration: 28’29”
Rating: 4 / 3.5 / 4 / 4.5 / 4 / 4 / 4 = 4.00
Comment: I was somewhat perplexed when I realized that overall, Anner Bylsma’s 1979 recording ended up with a similar rating to this newer one, with the earlier performance even beating this one in some movements. That said, both are valuable documents from the early stages of historically informed performances.
Jaap ter Linden, 1996
Harmonia mundi, ℗ 1997/1999
Artist: Jaap ter Linden (*1947, see also Wikipedia)
Instrument: Five-string violoncello piccolo by Antonio Amati (1560 – 1649) & Hieronymus Amati (1562 – 1630), Cremona, c.1600; baroque bow
Pitch: a’ = 415 Hz
See the Comparison Summary for more information on artist, instrument, recording location etc.
For general comments concerning recording quality and settings, acoustics, as well as the artist’s approach to the Cello Suites see the posting on the Suite No.1 for Cello Solo in G major, BWV 1007.
I. Prélude (4’35”)
Jaap ter Linden’s recording features a fluid tempo and natural musical flow. Gentle agogics support the phrasing in big arches. My main quibbles are about the sonority. In the bass and middle register, the sound of the recording (probably a combination of acoustics and instrument sonority) is somewhat overresonant and bulky, which obscures the articulation and affects the clarity. The e’ gut string on this precious violoncello piccolo from the Amati workshop sounds unbalanced, with excess resonances that make certain tones stand out in an unpleasant way. I wonder if a different recording setting could have mitigated this issue.
The semiquaver cadenza is fast, virtuosic and fluid, with long half-bar bow strokes in bars 85 and 86. In bar 96, the artist oddly altered the third quaver triplet from (e – d’ – g’) to (e – d’ – g♯’). This alteration is not present in any of the 18th century sources. It does not make sense because it includes a prominent augmented fourth or tritone (d’ – g♯’), which breaks the tonal sequence. The fact that the fifth quaver in the following bar is a g♯’ is not an excuse, as this is in a different melodic context.
II. Allemande (7’55”)
The recording offers gut string sonority with a slight but ubiquitous vibrato. However, for a HIP interpretation, this movement is somewhat disappointing. My main objection is the artist’s literal, straight rhythmic reading and uniform, broad articulation, which lacks flexibility and freedom of expression. One would expect a performance from 1995 to offer more agogics, Klangrede (Harnoncourt, 1983), and a narration.
III. Courante (3’41”)
In the Courante, Jaap ter Linden uses a light bow with gentle spiccato strokes for the quavers. The semiquavers are fluid, fluent, and smooth. My main reservations are about the limited agogics, and the fact that the performance often feels slightly rushed and out of breath. Shouldn’t a dance movement be more relaxed and allow for natural breathing?
IV. Sarabande (4’44”)
Although Jaap ter Linden’s Sarabande is slightly shorter than Thomas Demenga’s, it feels broader and slower. The artist focuses much more on the melody than Demenga does, consequently playing the chord notes merely as brief arpeggios, except in segments where the second voice moves in parallel sixths. It’s a beautiful chant of sorts. It comes in short, consecutive waves that tend to be tied together, forming very long phrases. These waves feel a tad idiosyncratic and predictable. More dynamic differentiation and relaxation of the tension between shorter phrases would improve the perceived structure and help listeners.
V./VI. Gavotte I — Gavotte II — Gavotte I da capo (4’33”)
Gavotte I
The first Gavotte feels a tad heavy with its sonorous, pounding four-string arpeggios. However, there is dance swaying, albeit almost clumsy—a peasant dance of sorts. The sonority is beautiful, and the articulation is careful and detailed.
Gavotte II
The second Gavotte is lighter yet still stays within the realm of a country dance. The artist did not aim for stark contrast with the sister movement. The two couplets don’t form strong internal contrasts either. Rather, they enrich the movement through their folksy character.
VII. Gigue (4’15”)
Jaap ter Linden beautifully performs the Gigue maintaining an excellent flow and dance-like sway despite the chords and large jumps. His articulation is careful and detailed, and his dynamics are well-differentiated. My only reservation is about the somewhat dull sound of the C string. This is particularly evident in the prominent low tones in jumps from the e’ and a strings down to the low bass and back up again. However, this may be a characteristic of this particular Amati violoncello piccolo.
Total Duration: 29’43”
Rating: 4 / 3.5 / 4 / 4 / 4 / 4 / 4.5 = 4.00
Comment: Jaap ter Linden is a key exponent of the HIP movement, alongside other prominent artists such as Anner Bylsma. His performances are solid and sound. The recording is certainly worth recommending, even though time has moved on in the HIP scene. The performance can no longer fully compete with more recent HIP recordings, beginning with Pieter Wispelwey.
Vito Paternoster, 1998
Magnatune.com, © 2003
Artist: Vito Paternoster (*1957, see also Wikipedia)
Instrument: Lorenzo Carcassi (1737 – 1775), Florence, 1792
See the Comparison Summary for more information on artist, instrument, recording location etc.
For general comments concerning recording quality and settings, acoustics, as well as the artist’s approach to the Cello Suites see the posting on the Suite No.1 for Cello Solo in G major, BWV 1007. Vito Paternoster’s cello is a standard, modernized four-string instrument.
I. Prélude (4’36”)
Vito Paternoster’s tempo is a tad faster than average. The very first notes are rhythmically sloppy in a strange way. Thereafter, the artist uses exaggerated agogics that sometimes disrupt the natural musical flow. Not only are the agogics hardly controlled, but the dynamics are as well, with occasional “spontaneous outbursts”. Additionally, the intonation is occasionally imperfect. While the articulation is not particularly rough, the overall impression is that of a “wild” performance.
II. Allemande (6’44”)
Vito Paternoster’s performance of the Allemande is notably faster than Anner Bylsma’s rendition from 1979. The articulation is careful, detailed, and light. The small notes in the melody voice form elaborate ornaments—arabesques, if you will. This is an outstanding aspect of Paternoster’s interpretation. The fast tempo should be an opportunity to expose the underlying 4/4 meter and create a proper 4/4 dance sway. Unfortunately, however, Paternoster fails to achieve these effects, which is a missed opportunity.
III. Courante (3’13”)
Vito Paternoster’s performance of the Courante is faster than anyone else’s. He is so fast that the tempo serves no purpose other than to showcase virtuosity. There is no dance swaying, and many semiquaver passages sound superficial and hardly articulated, leaving the listener exhausted. Paternoster exacerbates the issue by adding numerous ornaments, even in the first passes. The performance is undoubtedly virtuosic. If only it left room to breathe and enjoy!
IV. Sarabande (3’51”)
Vito Paternoster once again offers the fastest performance in this comparison. Interestingly, though, the first part does not feel too fast. Unsurprisingly, the artist adds ornaments not just to the repeats, but also to a lesser degree to the first pass, which I find questionable. Paternoster’s vibrato is too strong and nervous.
In the second part (bars 9 – 32), Paternoster limits added ornaments to the first segment which is dominated by long notes (half notes and longer). Here, though, the tempo often feels excessive and pushed, starting with the appearance of quavers, and in the bars with paired crotchets in parallel sixths. There is just too much unrest. Shouldn’t a slow movement allow for some calm, relaxed, and reflective moments?
V./VI. Gavotte I — Gavotte II — Gavotte I da capo (4’32”)
Gavotte I
For once, Vito Paternoster selected a “normal” tempo. The tempo of the first Gavotte is slightly below average, while the tempo of the second Gavotte is slightly above average.
Gavotte I feels heavy due to the disruptive broadening of three- or four-string arpeggios. The four-string chords are especially broad and carry a prominent, nearly explosive accent. These chords prevent a natural flow and preclude any harmonious dance swaying. They make the piece feel unruly. Additionally, the intonation is not always clean, particularly in the chords. I suspect that using a five-string instrument would have helped maintain clean intonation.
Gavotte II
The slightly faster second Gavotte has lighter articulation, especially in the ritornello. The latter feels almost capricious with its spiccato crotchets. Unfortunately, the two couplets don’t quite match the spirit of the ritornello. The first couplet disrupts the pattern with its limping ostinato, which oddly has accents on the weak crotchet beats. The second couplet is substantially faster than the ritornello and introduces unnecessary rhythmic discontinuities.
VII. Gigue (4’07”)
The Gigue begins with energetic and almost theatrical bow strokes, using joyful, light, and capricious spiccato articulation for détaché quavers. In bar 9, however, the performance goes beyond capriciousness, as the artist’s propensity to exaggerate articulation and rhythm takes over. It is almost grotesque how he splits three- and four-string arpeggio chords while also rhythmically distorting the attached quaver triplet and exaggerating the emphasis on the first triplet note. This disrupts the rhythmic flow and prevents a persistent dance feeling. Additionally, the articulation often feels coarse and superficial. The intonation also often feels careless.
Total Duration: 27’02”
Rating: 3 / 3.5 / 3 / 3 / 3 / 3.5 / 3 = 3.14
Comment: As the former principal cellist of I Musici di Roma, Vito Paternoster is certainly familiar with Baroque music and historically informed performance practice. With his recording of the Cello Suites, however, he offers an unusual interpretation, revealing a propensity toward extremes, such as an unusually fast tempo and articulation that often touches on grotesqueness. He ignores conventions, seeking unique, personal solutions. This recording is certainly not to everybody’s taste.

Pieter Wispelwey, 1998
Channel Classics, ℗/© 1998
Artist: Pieter Wispelwey (*1962, see also Wikipedia)
Instrument: Anonymous five-string violoncello piccolo, 18th century; baroque bow
Pitch: a’ = 415 Hz
See the Comparison Summary for more information on artist, instrument, recording location etc.
For general comments concerning recording quality and settings, acoustics, as well as the artist’s approach to the Cello Suites see the posting on the Suite No.1 for Cello Solo in G major, BWV 1007.
I. Prélude (4’53”)
As expected, Pieter Wispelwey’s 1998 recording is excellent. In my listening sequence, which goes from slow to fast, it is number 10 out of 28. It’s tempting to juxtapose this with Anastasia Kobekina’s recent recording, as they have similar timings and use the same pitch. One could see Wispelwey’s performance as a precursor to Anastasia Kobekina’s recording, even though the latter surpasses it in terms of freedom in agogics, dynamics, phrasing, and expression.
Of course, the 27-year age gap between the two recordings is evident. Wispelwey’s articulation is light and detailed, and his performance is exemplarily clear, even in the bariolage motifs. The three-string chords in bars 98 and 99 are notable for their brevity and directness. The interpretation is far less outgoing than Kobekina’s in terms of agogics and phrasing. It feels more coherent and tamed, less extreme. Therefore, it may suit listeners who prefer a more moderate yet historically informed approach.
II. Allemande (8’24”)
The tempo of the Allemande in Pieter Wispelwey’s first recording is very similar to that in Anner Bylsma’s 1992 recording. Unlike Bylsma, though, Wispelwey uses subtle agogics, creating a natural flow and sway in every crotchet period. The interpretation breathes harmoniously. I particularly like that Wispelwey’s performance is devoid of grand gestures. It feels introverted and intimate—beautiful!
III. Courante (3’46”)
The timing of Pieter Wispelwey’s 1998 recording of the Courante is almost exactly on the average of this comparison. The performance feels natural and free of idiosyncrasies and exaggerations. It is excellent. My only minor quibble is with the little disruptions after jumps down to the C string. The problem isn’t the jumps down, but rather the delay when jumping back up after the bass note. The most prominent examples are in bars 13 and 14, though the upward jumps in bars 32 and 33 also exhibit this issue to a lesser degree. However, these are minor points. Overall, the performance is virtuosic, joyful, and light.
IV. Sarabande (5’59”)
This is the second Sarabande recording I’m listening to, moving from slow to faster performances. After Pierre Fournier’s interpretation. Pieter Wispelwey’s performance left me baffled. Fournier dragged out every note endlessly. At almost the same pace, Wispelwey converts every bar and every phrase into a verse in a long poem, or rather, an intense and intimate lament, filled with sadness and longing. It is infinitely touching and soothing. Wispelwey achieves this with mere traces of vibrato, and yet he takes the piece to an intense climax in bars 21 – 28. My only minor quibble with the interpretation is the occasional tendency towards Nachdrücken.
V./VI. Gavotte I — Gavotte II — Gavotte I da capo (4’09”)
Gavotte I
I’m tempted to call this a perfect, historically informed performance. I don’t mean cold, featureless technical perfection, but rather, a performance where picking out details risks affecting the impression of a perfect balance of tempo, dance swaying, naturalness, and carefulness in articulation, phrasing, and dynamics. Pieter Wispelwey’s performance is harmonious throughout and does not depict the Gavotte as rustic or particularly folksy. Instead, the piece exudes joy, lightness, and peaceful playfulness.
Gavotte II
The second Gavotte is gentler and softer, but does not contrast starkly with the sister movement. Rather, it is a harmonious complement. Similarly, there is internal harmony in the interpretation. The first couplet with its ostinato accompaniment matches the spirit of the ritornello. Similarly, the musette (second couplet) stands out mainly through its bagpipe texture, though it is a tad faster than the surrounding ritornelli. Beautiful!
VII. Gigue (4’05”)
For the Gigue, Pieter Wispelwey used a fluid tempo. Both articulation and sonority are light throughout, and this movement has a distinct dance sway. The latter has only minor limitations, such as when large jumps and chords momentarily disrupt the regularity of the flow. In particular, the dissonant chords and quaver triplets at the beginning of bars 21 and 23 stand out almost like erratic blocks. Rather than playing over these impediments, Wispelwey maintains his careful and detailed articulation. This is an excellent final dance!
Total Duration: 31’14”
Rating: 5 / 4.5 / 4.5 / 4.5 / 5 / 5 / 4.5 = 4.71
Comment: A masterful interpretation, near the very top of the list. Highly recommended. One indication of the performance’s quality and level is that, 14 years later, in his second recording, the artist did not see a need to switch to a different tempo. Among the three artists with two recordings in this comparison (including Anner Bylsma, and Jean-Guihen Queyras), Wispelwey is the most consistent in his tempo selection.
Paolo Pandolfo, 2000 — Viola da gamba
Glossa Platinum, © 2004
Artist: Paolo Pandolfo (*1964, see also Wikipedia)
Instrument: Seven-string Viola da gamba by Lorenzo Carcassi (1737 – 1775), Florence, 1792
Pitch: a’ = 415 Hz
See the Comparison Summary for more information on artist, instrument, recording location etc.
For general comments concerning recording quality and settings, acoustics, as well as the artist’s approach to the Cello Suites see the posting on the Suite No.1 for Cello Solo in G major, BWV 1007.
I. Prélude (4’10”)
Paolo Pandolfo’s Prélude interpretation is not comparable to that of Myriam Rignol, even though both play on a seven-string viola da gamba. Rignol transposed the piece a full tone down to C major for her instrument, but otherwise followed Bach’s notation to show how the music sounds on her instrument. Pandolfo’s approach is different. He kept the piece in D major, using the composition to showcase the potential of the viola da gamba through Bach’s work. However, in this movement he largely does not try to “recompose” the music. Instead, he uses articulation and dynamics to highlight the instrument’s rich sonorities, adding some extra ornaments around the cadenza.
Pandolfo’s goal is not to present every detail of the composition exactly as it was written in Anna Magdalena Bach’s manuscript copy. For example, he is quite liberal with the slurs in the score. In the bariolage motifs, he often plays both tied notes on two strings, adding an octave below. This creates an astounding sonority.
Only after reaching the peak notes (g’) in bar 73 does Pandolfo add some nice extra ornaments (typically inverted mordents and short trills), which complement Bach’s own explicit ornaments in bars 78 – 80. His interpretation is among the fastest in the comparison. Nevertheless, his performance feels effortless and playful, and the semiquaver cadenza is very virtuosic, particularly in bars 85 and 86, which he plays détaché throughout. After the cadenza, he softens his tone for the very gentle and intimate arpeggio chords in bars 98 and 99.
Even in the absence of substantial alterations, Paolo Pandolfo’s performance should not be seen as competing with the “regular” cello interpretations. It is truly beautiful nonetheless.
II. Allemande (6’41”)
In the hands of Paolo Pandolfo, Bach’s Allemande receives a rather liberal treatment. For one, the artist harmonizes the movement by adding numerous chords, and the internal resonances of the instrument further contribute to a continuous, rich, and “space-filling” sonority. Even more notably, Pandolfo interprets Bach’s ornamented melody line with extraordinary rhythmic freedom, adding his own “curly” ornamentation on top.
The result is stunning and fascinating. I won’t attempt a detailed description. Instead, I’m sharing my general impressions. Just like the Prélude, this is not a recomposition: Pandolfo plays virtually all of the notes in Bach’s score. However, he combines this with “extreme” agogics, added ornaments, harmonization chords, and a fluid pace.
The overall impression is that of an authentic piece for the viola da gamba. It is unlike the few compositions Bach wrote for the instrument, such as the three sonatas for harpsichord and viola da gamba. To me, the movement feels more like it’s from the French gambist school or maybe by a “specialist” composer, such as Carl Friedrich Abel (1723 – 1787). Nevertheless, listening to this piece is an utterly enjoyable experience.
III. Courante (3’55”)
The Courante offers another fabulous experience. Once again, Pandolfo technically plays all of Bach’s notes. However, he uses different means to express his personality. He doesn’t use ornamentation. Instead, he changes the piece’s character by harmonizing it, adding numerous chords underneath the melody. He is doing this in other movements, too, but this time, the chords take on a more central role. They add harmony, of course—harmonies that are clearly not Bach’s, but rather Pandolfo’s and/or a gambist’s genuine style. Moreover, Pandolfo’s chords are not just single notes on a second string, but powerful arpeggios that appear to drive the piece by adding rhythm, structure, and momentum.
Often, Pandolfo’s chords mark the first beat in a motif or bar, typically preceded by a chord on the associated upbeat. The verve of these chords energizes the associated motif, filling it with life and vitality. They fill the movement with their gorgeous, warm, and rounded sonority. This movement is an experience to behold.
IV. Sarabande (5’17”)
In the Sarabande, the central piece of the suite, Paolo Pandolfo refrains from “recomposing” Bach’s music, as he does in many movements. He keeps the piece in D major and leaves the melody largely intact. However, he makes slight alterations to the chords. Some of these alterations, such as the addition of a bass note, are inspired by—or perhaps required for—the seven-string layout of the viola da gamba. Prominent examples include the full-sounding chords on the upbeat to bar 25. In the repeats, Pandolfo also includes a few subtle, non-intrusive ornaments, including the ascending figure on the last note of the first part, which ends in anticipating the first chord of the repeat.
Pandolfo’s interpretation occupies a position between Myriam Rignol’s viola da gamba performance, which is formally truthful to the cello score (albeit in C major), and Lucile Boulanger’s transcription, which reads Bach’s score more freely.
I would not call Pandolfo’s interpretation a lament. It is lyrical, infinitely calm, and reflective. The artist carefully plays out every chord, exploring the harmonies and intervals, and savoring the rich internal harmonies and resonances of the bass viol. It is a heavenly delight!
V./VI. Gavotte I — Gavotte II — Gavotte I da capo (4’56”)
Gavotte I
Pandolfo plays the first Gavotte with verve and momentum. The groups of arpeggio chords are seamlessly integrated into the flow. They don’t disrupt the rhythm, but rather propel the performance forward. This does not preclude gentle, subtle, and ravishingly beautiful phrase endings. The artist closely adheres to the text in Anna Magdalena Bach’s manuscript copy, adding only a few inverted mordents, and retaining the spirit of the original composition. It is a harmonious and truly marvelous performance.
Gavotte II
The second Gavotte stands out in this comparison not only because it is the slowest performance, but also because of its unique character. The atmosphere is completely different. There is total introversion and calmness. The performance is gentle and soft, lacking strong accents or harsh features. Even the arpeggio chords are gentle, blending into the phrases. The basic crotchet pace is similar to that in Gavotte I, but every four-bar phrase begins sotto voce and ends with a subtle, retracting fermata and a short pause for reflection prior to the next phrase. Moreover, the artist uses a lovely jeu inégal in the quaver motifs almost throughout. The one obvious exception is the gently flowing musette part. This is a unique and ravishingly beautiful performance—an absolute gem!
The original structure of the second Gavotte is (AA)-(BACABACA), or |:A:||:BACA:|. Pandolfo changes this to (AA)-(BABACACA). In other words, he splits the second part into two segments, repeating each one individually.
VII. Gigue (4’15”)
Paolo Pandolfo concludes the Suite with sonorous fireworks, once again showcasing the full range of sounds his instrument can produce. His interpretation is both beautiful and enthralling. The performance encompasses the entirety of Bach’s composition, but features frequent added ornaments, adapted to both the piece and the instrument. Additionally, the artist uses the specific capabilities of the viol to mark key notes with extra chords, both in the bass and occasionally in the descant. Fascinating!
Total Duration: 29’13”
Rating: 5 / 5 / 5 / 5 / 5 / 5 / 5 = 5.00
Comment: Some might consider it devious to give the highest ratings to a performance of the Cello Suites on a viola da gamba. This recording cannot be compared to cello performances, nor should it be seen as competing with them. The rating expresses the amount of listening pleasure I derive from this performance. In a way, that is also the case for cello performances. However, the relationship between the performance and the available sources (i.e., Bach’s presumed intent) plays a much larger role in cello performances than in relatively free transcriptions such as Pandolfo’s. Therefore, I maintain that this recording receives the highest possible recommendation, even if it is not meant to replace any cello recording.
Steven Isserlis, 2005
hyperion, ℗ 2007
Artist: Steven Isserlis (*1958, see also Wikipedia)
Instrument: Cello “De Munck-Feuermann” (& Parisot) by Antonio Stradivari (1644 – 1737), Cremona, 1730
See the Comparison Summary for more information on artist, instrument, recording location etc.
For general comments concerning recording quality and settings, acoustics, as well as the artist’s approach to the Cello Suites see the posting on the Suite No.1 for Cello Solo in G major, BWV 1007. Steven Isserlis’ cello is a standard, modernized four-string instrument.
I. Prélude (4’34”)
Steven Isserlis’ articulation is carefully, and the artist pays attention to the details of the notation. He does apply agogics and differentiated dynamics. Overall, however, it is a modern interpretation with ubiquitous vibrato, which makes it appear old-fashioned compared to today’s HIP performances. I’m not tempted to apply the term Klangrede (Harnoncourt, 1983) to this performance.
My main reservation about the interpretation is that it tries to make this a “big” piece (or a big interpretation?), adding grandeur and excess intensity and sonority. Is this an interpretation for the big stage? Some may like this performance style, but to me, despite the differentiation and detail, it sometimes seems to roll over the piece like a steamroller. Shouldn’t there be more room for subtlety?
II. Allemande (7’37”)
Compared to traditional interpretations by musicians such as Pierre Fournier or Mstislav Rostropovich, Steven Isserlis’ interpretation of the Allemande uses lighter articulation. However, with its ubiquitous vibrato and emphatic dynamics on most longer notes (semiquaver and above), the interpretation still feels overly romantic and far from any HIP approach. This is also evident in the literal reading of the note values, which attempts to maintain their relative proportions. This makes the smaller note values feel excessively melodic rather than ornamental. There are some agogics, but nothing reminiscent of Baroque Klangrede. There’s more to this music!
III. Courante (3’27”)
Steven Isserlis’s springy dynamics and fast pace, together with his ubiquitous vibrato, create the impression of a high-tension performance. The tempo is one of the fastest and occasionally feels slightly pushed, causing a slight loss in momentum. Strangely, Isserlis decided to split many of the slurred semiquaver quadruplets, often even playing them détaché. All this contributes to the impression of a romantic rather than baroque performance, overly busy, and lacking breathing and agogics, up to the unnecessary, grumbling trill on the final D note.
IV. Sarabande (4’35”)
Given its permanent and pronminent vibrato and the broad, but gentle articulation, Isserlis’ performance is definitely not strictly historically informed. The articulation is not just broad, but cautious and non-percussive, with a slight tendency toward soft transitions, belly notes, and occasionally also Nachdrücken. It is far from the “thickness” of performances by Pierre Fournier of Mstislav Rostropovich, but still feels overly sweet and romantic.
V./VI. Gavotte I — Gavotte II — Gavotte I da capo (3’09”)
Gavotte I
I wish this interpretation was a little more playful, relaxed, and lighthearted rather than always energetic, driven, earnest, and determined. In some ways, the performance also feels superficial, notably in the agogics in the quaver groups. There is also very little, if any, sense of dance.
Gavotte II
The second Gavotte is less driven and energetic. The ritornello is particularly subtle, with a hint of jeu inégal in the first few bars. The first couplet with the ostinato accompaniment feels mechanical. The second couplet (musette) is loud and driven. I don’t think Scottish bagpipes are the right model for this segment. I’m rather thinking of smaller, simpler bagpipes, as used by shepherds and peasants in the countryside. The couplets lack joy, fun, and a folksy tone.
In Gavotte II, Isserlis omits the second repeat. This is unfortunate because listeners experience three instances of the first Gavotte and four instances of the ritornello in the second Gavotte, but only hear the two folksy couplets once.
VII. Gigue (4’08”)
Steven Isserlis’ performance is energetic, clean, and controlled. Unfortunately, there is very little agogics, and the performance is too regular, rhythmically rigid, and static. While it is technically superb, and not even the arpeggio chords affect the regularity of the flow. But shouldn’t there be more life in this music?
Total Duration: 27’30”
Rating: 3.5 / 3.5 / 3.5 / 3.5 / 3.5 / 3.5 / 3.5 = 3.50
Comment: Steven Isserlis is undoubtedly one of the most important cellists of the past 30+ years. However, Baroque music plays a minor role in his repertoire. He should focus on his core repertoire of classical, Romantic, and post-Romantic music. While his recording may appeal to his fan community, anyone who has acquired even just a slight taste for historically informed performances will not really enjoy it.
Jean-Guihen Queyras, 2007
harmonia mundi, ℗ 2007
Artist: Jean-Guihen Queyras (*1967, see also Wikipedia)
Instrument: Gioffredo Cappa (1644 – 1717), Saluzzo, Italy, 1696
See the Comparison Summary for more information on artist, instrument, recording location etc.
For general comments concerning recording quality and settings, acoustics, as well as the artist’s approach to the Cello Suites see the posting on the Suite No.1 for Cello Solo in G major, BWV 1007. Jean-Guihen Queyras’ cello is a standard, modernized four-string instrument.
I. Prélude (4’28”)
For his first recording, Jean-Guihen Queyras chose a pace similar to Anner Bylsma’s in his 1992 recording, which was rather fluid. However, Queyras articulates every note carefully. His performance is differentiated in dynamics but lacks the amount of Klangrede (Harnoncourt, 1983) found in recent HIP recordings at the level of quaver triplet motifs. Instead, the artist focuses on the bigger phrases and on the four beats of the 12/8 rhythm. He accomplishes this without neglecting the “minor” quaver notes. For example, in the bariolage motifs, the tied note is always clearly identifiable, even though it is very close in sonority.
Queyras’ performance may not exhibit showmanship, but his playful style is convincing. Even the most virtuosic passages seem natural. Unsurprisingly, he plays the semiquaver “cadenza” with slurs, not détaché, let alone spiccato or the like. It is compelling in its cohesion, presenting the movement as one single, coherent structure. My only quibble about the interpretation is that it occasionally leaves little room to breathe. A little more agogics would have been helpful. It’s a beautiful recording that builds a bridge between “classic” interpretations and true HIP performances.
II. Allemande (7’34”)
Jean-Guihen Queyras’ 2007 recording of the Allemande is gentle and unhurried, featuring a bright, largely vibrato-free tone. The artist avoids dense legato, discharging longer notes. The performance is dominated by calm, natural phrasing and agogics, in which each of the broad phrases includes its own narration. These blend seamlessly to create a continuous narrative that maintains tension throughout. Yet it also allows the listener to breathe with the phrasing—it’s beautiful!
In the first pass, Queyras uses the simpler version of bar 2 from Anna Magdalena Bach’s manuscript copy (see above). In the repeat, he switches to the “richer” version from the other 18th-century sources. One fascinating aspect of the performance is how the chains of small notes are treated rhythmically freely, as ornaments rather than melodic elements. The low notes at the beginning of bars 11 and 12 are notable; Queyras plays them softly, introspectively and almost secretively.
III. Courante (3’33”)
Jean-Guihen Queyras’ 2007 performance of the Courante was notably faster than his 2023 recording. While not the fastest, Queyras’ 2007 tempo is still at a point where artists in other recordings begin to struggle. Amazingly, even though it is faster than Bylsma’s 1979 and Emmanuelle Bertrand’s 2019 performances, Queyras’ performance does not feel fast, nor even a trace rushed. Rather, it is relaxed and clear in every detail—simply masterful. The one thing which still makes me prefer Queyras’ most recent recording is that the latter feels freer, allowing for more agogics, dance swaying, and expression.
IV. Sarabande (4’31”)
In my comparison, I’m progressing from slower to faster performances. Jean-Guihen Queyras’ interpretation is in position 19, and the tempo is clearly above average. The tempo change from the preceding recording (Steven Isserlis) looked harmless, yet something about Queyras’ interpretation felt very different. My first reaction was that the slurred crotchet pairs felt too fast, and I wondered if the previous artists were applying slight jeu inégal. Of course, this was not the case—everyone plays these as written. What happened is that Queyras’ interpretation is the first one so far to play this movement in proper 3/2 time, as specified in the score.
Once I realized this, I rapidly adjusted to the interpretation and then the performance felt like a revelation. Even though the tempo is faster, when played in 3/2 time, the piece does not appear fast. Rather, the artist’s playing feels calm, serene, idyllic, and peaceful, free of conflict and sadness. One advantage of the faster pace is that there is no need for additional ornamentation. Queyras’ subtle dynamics and the careful articulation are enough to fill the movement with meaning, expression, and emotion. Beautiful!
V./VI. Gavotte I — Gavotte II — Gavotte I da capo (3’20”)
Gavotte I
Along with Anner Bylsma’s 1979 recording, this is the fastest performance in the comparison. The artist has no issues with the tempo. The performance is technically excellent, with good phrasing and detailed articulation. However, the fast pace becomes the dominant feature, leaving little space or time for agogics and real Klangrede, let alone “free” dance swaying.
Gavotte II
The same is true here: with his fast pace, the artist leaves everyone else behind in terms of tempo. I don’t see why the second Gavotte needs to be that much faster than its sister movement. The listener can hardly enjoy the details in this movement. The first couplet is a tad calmer. However, in its brevity, it can hardly compensate for the rushed ritornelli. The musette seems to compete with virtuosic bagpipe music, leaving little room for the cozy, expressive aspects of this couplet.
VII. Gigue (4’01”)
This is one of the faster Gigue performances, and it is clearly played on a modern instrument. It is fluid, but does not feel rushed, featuring a natural dance-like sway. Queyras’s playing is detailed, and the articulation is always clear. The flow and phrasing feel entirely natural.
Total Duration: 27’28”
Rating: 4.5 / 5 / 4.5 / 5 / 4 / 4 / 4.5 = 4.50
Comment: Beautiful and highly recommended, especially for non-HIP audiences. That said, with the exception of two movements (second Gavotte and Gigue) I prefer the newer, 2023 recording.
Ophélie Gaillard, 2010
Aparté / harmonia mundi, ℗/© 2011
Artist: Ophélie Gaillard (*1974, see also Wikipedia)
Instrument: Anonymous Flemish five-string violoncello piccolo; baroque bow
Pitch: a’ = 415 Hz
See the Comparison Summary for more information on artist, instrument, recording location etc.
For general comments concerning recording quality and settings, acoustics, as well as the artist’s approach to the Cello Suites see the posting on the Suite No.1 for Cello Solo in G major, BWV 1007.
I. Prélude (4’33”)
I’m listening to this after Steven Isserlis‘ 2005 recording, which has the same timing as Ophélie Gaillard’s. In comparison, Isserlis’ recording sounds gross and loud. Conversely, Gaillard’s HIP performance on gut strings initially feels almost dull. Some of this difference is due to the recording setup and the acoustics. A juxtaposition requires some adjustment on the part of the listener.
Ophélie Gaillard’s Prélude recording is an honest, sincere, and valid historically informed performance. The articulation is clear and clean, devoid of unnecessary show effects. The bariolage motifs are easily identifiable. In softer segments, especially the echo passages, the articulation shifts to a gentle spiccato. The sonority is excellent, balanced and consistent across the range. The intonation is clear up to the highest positions (using a violoncello piccolo certainly helps!), and the articulation retains clarity throughout the virtuosic semiquaver cadenza. Beautiful!
II. Allemande (7’28”)
Ophélie Gaillard’s tempo is fluid, allowing the adornments in the melody line to be what they are—primarily ornaments, not melody. As stated elsewhere, there should be no need for extra ornamentation in this movement, given Bach’s already rich and explicit ornaments. However, the artist adds a fair number of her own rich and inventive ornaments. She limits them to the repeats, though, which makes them legitimate. I like the artist’s rhythmically flexible playing and liberal agogics. However, I still occasionally feel the need for extra “breathing space”, i.e., more structuring at the level of mid-size phrases, as opposed to seamlessly linking several of these phrases to very long arches.
III. Courante (3’49”)
The timing in Ophélie Gaillard’s performance of the Courante is identical to Pierre Fournier’s interpretation. Like Fournier, she does not play the quavers strictly staccato. Apart from the slurs (mostly on semiquavers), Bach did not specify the articulation, so it is up to the artist’s discretion how to play the quaver motifs. Unlike Fournier, nothing in Ophélie Gaillard’s interpretation feels schematic or idiosyncratic. Rather, along with her agogics and dynamics, her articulation is part of a differentiated and virtuosic musical language with lively expression and phrasing. The only quibble I have is with the slightly muffled acoustics. Beautiful!
IV. Sarabande (4’38”)
This is a calm, introverted performance at a pace slightly above average. The interpretation avoids grand gestures and does not attempt to make this piece feel overly big. It suffers from some idiosyncrasies, though. There is a noticeable tendency to let individual notes swell. Typically, this swelling is linear, but occasionally, it borders on Nachdrücken.
In the repeats, Ophélie Gaillard adds numerous ornaments. Some of these may feel unexpected and unnecessary. This is the seventeenth recording in my listening sequence, and it has the most added ornaments so far. While many of Gaillard’s ornaments are inventive and original, they do not necessarily fit the style of the composition well. Furthermore, the more “special” and inventive an ornament is, the more careful one should be about repeating it, especially in close succession, as this makes them feel idiosyncratic.
V./VI. Gavotte I — Gavotte II — Gavotte I da capo (4’28”)
Gavotte I
For a galanterie, the first Gavotte feels a little too earnest. However, the articulation, agogics, and phrasing are careful. The artist adds several ornaments, mostly inverted mordents and the occasional short trill. My main quibble with the recording is that many of these embellishments feel idiosyncratic. The majority of the descending quaver quadruplets, such as in the first half of bar 2, bear an added inverted mordent which predictably occurs on the third note.
Gavotte II
The second Gavotte is lighter and more elegant. It is easier to associate with the term galanterie. I have one minor quibble: in the first couplet (after the double bar), the ostinato (lower voice) is too dominant and almost covers the melody. The second couplet is lovely, and the added inverted mordents reinforce the illusion of a bagpipe. Here, the embellishments don’t feel idiosyncratic, but rather like authentic bagpipe ornaments. Once again, the drone is rather dominant, though not as much as the ostinato in the first couplet.
VII. Gigue (4’30”)
In the Gigue, Ophélie Gaillard selected a moderate tempo. Her articulation is mostly mellow, lacking “bite” or percussive attack. For the most part, her articulation leans toward “belly” dynamics. The exception is passages with détaché semiquavers, which she plays staccato. Unfortunately there is little sense of dance, let alone fun and joy, in this performance. Unsurprisingly, the interpretation often lacks drive and momentum. It rather sometimes feels a tad defensive.
Total Duration: 29’26”
Rating: 4.5 / 4 / 4 / 4 / 4 / 4.5 / 3.5 = 4.07
Comment: This is a sound, solid interpretation. I can recommend it because it has no major flaws. However, it does not significantly stand out from the many recent HIP performances.
Pieter Wispelwey, 2012
Evil Penguin Records Classic, 2017
Artist: Pieter Wispelwey (*1962, see also Wikipedia)
Instrument: anonymous five-string violoncello piccolo, 18th century; gut strings and baroque bow
Pitch: a’ = 392 Hz
See the Comparison Summary for more information on artist, instrument, recording location etc.
For general comments concerning recording quality and settings, acoustics, as well as the artist’s approach to the Cello Suites see the posting on the Suite No.1 for Cello Solo in G major, BWV 1007.
I. Prélude (4’48”)
In terms of tempo (timing) and general approach, Pieter Wispelwey’s newer recording is similar to his first recording from 1998. However, the newer recording feels more direct, with more detailed articulation and dynamics. The focus is on expression rather than the aesthetics of sound and articulation. The semiquaver cadenza is not only astoundingly virtuosic, but also playful, expressive, and liberated. Overall, there is more differentiation. One example is the articulation of the chords in bars 98 and 99, which initially retain the resoluteness and vehemence of the 1998 performance, but then soften and broaden for a smooth and gentle transition into the closing bars.
One key feature is that it’s one of only two recordings at the low pitch of a’ = 392 Hz, which helps achieve an impressive sonority in the bass while keeping the top of the range closer to the human voice. It’s one of my favorite interpretations, for sure. I very much like the full sonority in the bass, as well as the intensely singing gut string tone of the top register.
II. Allemande (7’58”)
In his second recording, Pieter Wispelwey changed the tempo of the Allemande from moderate to slightly above average, while maintaining the calmness of the 1998 recording. He also changed the pitch to a’ = 392 Hz, bringing the sound of the violoncello piccolo closer to that of a regular cello while maintaining the intense singing quality of the soprano register. The new recording is more radical, limiting the vibrato and leaving the slightly stinging quality of the e’ string. This interpretation feels more natural and organic. The phrases feel longer, and the narration and sonority feel richer. It is a beautiful and harmonious performance.
III. Courante (3’32”)
Between his 2007 and 2023 recordings, Jean-Guihen Queyras slowed the pace of the Courante. In contrast, Pieter Wispelwey switched to a faster tempo between his 1998 recording and this one. What a masterpiece this turned out to be! The minor shortcomings of the first recording are gone. The new interpretation is light and effortless, a true swaying and jolly dance in 3/4 time. There is more differentiation in the articulation, with the quavers varying between détaché and a dry, almost capricious spiccato. The music flows, breathes, and sways in broad phrases, with every motif contributing to the narration. Beautiful!
IV. Sarabande (5’50”)
Compared to his earlier recording from 1998, Pieter Wispelwey’s second recording is only a tad faster. Otherwise, the two recordings are very similar. The instrument is the same, but now the tuning is lowered by half a tone, resulting in a darker, more fragile sound.
The newer interpretation is very similar. The differences are small, gradual, and subtle, yet noticeable. Here are my impressions: the sonority of the recording is a little drier, which at first makes the performance feel a tad more objective. There is also less vibrato, and the articulation is lighter. Nachdrücken is no longer an issue. The interpretation may initially feel more distant and less expressive. However, the performance also reveals the piece to be an intimate duet of two voices that often move in parallel sixths. The third and (fragmentary) fourth voices primarily add harmony and, to a lesser degree, rhythmic structure.
One might say that in the new recording, Wispelwey toned down his personal expression to let Bach’s music speak for itself. But of course, his detailed articulation, dynamics, and agogics retain their emotional and expressive intensity, now in an atmosphere of solitude. It is very touching nonetheless.
V./VI. Gavotte I — Gavotte II — Gavotte I da capo (4’09”)
Gavotte I
I wouldn’t dare call Pieter Wispelwey’s 2012 recording of Gavotte I “more radical” than his 1998 recording of the same piece. It is slightly more expressive and articulate, though. However, it can’t quite match the warmth, inner harmony, and natural musical flow of the earlier recording.
Gavotte II
Compared to the 1998 recording, there is slightly more contrast between the two sister movements. The ritornello, and especially the first couplet of Gavotte II is lighter and more pronounced in dynamics and articulation. The ostinato crotchets in the couplet seem almost capricious, but never devolve into caricature or mere entertainment. This time, the tempo doesn’t change for the musette. However, this segment is also slightly more articulate and contoured in dynamics. There is even a playful note in the ornament at the end of bar 16 in the repeat.
VII. Gigue (4’07”)
As previously mentioned, Pieter Wispelway maintained the same tempo as in his first recording from 1998. Of course, there is still a noticeable difference. The lower pitch in the 2012 recording (a full tone below today’s standard pitch of a’=440 Hz) results in a warmer, slightly darker and fuller sonority. As in the Gavottes, the new recording feels more expressive and articulate. It also feels less polished, as it does not hide the edges of the gut string sound. Most importantly, the movement is more compelling overall in phrasing and flow.
Total Duration: 30’24”
Rating: 5 / 5 / 5 / 5 / 4.5 / 5 / 5 = 4.93
Comment: If you are looking for a smooth, gentle interpretation, then this recording is probably not the best choice for you. However, if you are looking for an expressive and articulate performance with radical HIP articulation, agogics, and sonority, there are few others that match this interpretation. It’s one of my all-time favorites, and I highly recommend it!

Isang Enders, 2013
Edel Germany / Berlin Classics, ℗/© 2014
Artist: Isang Enders (*1988, see also Wikipedia)
Instrument: “Joseph Gagliano, filius fecit 1720“; modern bow
See the Comparison Summary for more information on artist, instrument, recording location etc.
For general comments concerning recording quality and settings, acoustics, as well as the artist’s approach to the Cello Suites see the posting on the Suite No.1 for Cello Solo in G major, BWV 1007. Isang Enders’ cello is a standard, modernized four-string instrument.
I. Prélude (4’19”)
Compared to HIP performances, Isang Enders’ interpretation makes his instrument sound almost like a viola. This may be due in part to the recording setup. The sound lacks warmth and resonance. Compared to performances using gut strings, it sounds metallic, technical, and cold. The articulation is light and often sounds like flying spiccato. Sure, the artist’s technical abilities are astounding, and one might call the performance technically perfect. The dynamics are differentiated, and I can’t deny the presence of phrasing and agogics, but the performance still lacks the human element and fails to touch the listener, possibly due to sonority alone.
II. Allemande (7’26”)
As expected, the Allemande is technically clean and flawless,. The vibrato is mostly discreet, though it occasionally tends toward nervousness. Unfortunately, there is a tendency to let long notes swell. The performance does not feel rigid or stiff. However, despite traces of agogics, the execution is far too metric and literal, devoid of expression, poetry, and lyricism.
III. Courante (3’34”)
This is a fast performance of the Courante, though not the fastest. Isang Enders articulates carefully and clearly. He uses agogics and phrasing. Nevertheless, the primary impression is that it is “too fast”. There are no major mishaps, and the occasional imperfections are subtle. Still, the performance leaves the impression that the artist has pushed himself to the limit, to the point where he needs to slow down slightly in difficult passages. There isn’t much, if any, dance swaying, and the overall effect is one of a rushed, restless performance.
IV. Sarabande (4’56”)
At best, this is an unremarkable interpretation that conveys little to no expression, let alone emotion. There is a tendency toward “belly dynamics” with each bow stroke. All notes are played correctly, but with little agogics and no Klangrede (Harnoncourt, 1983). Vibrato is often used without purpose, such as to ornament or highlight specific notes. The arpeggio on chords is played mechanically.
V./VI. Gavotte I — Gavotte II — Gavotte I da capo (4’10”)
Gavotte I
This is an overly careful interpretation. Although the execution is perfect, the excessive effort to play every arpeggio chord accurately and well-shaped causes the performance to lack a rhythmic foundation. This destroys any sense of dance or lightness of galanterie.
Gavotte II
The second Gavotte is noticeably faster and lighter. Since there are only two arpeggio chords in the ritornello, they are less disruptive than in Gavotte I. Despite the faster pace, the first couplet with the ostinato accompaniment feels heavy, due to the frequent “belly accents” on the crotchets. The piece would feel better if the artist allowed himself to embody the folksy dance character of this music.
VII. Gigue (4’24”)
I can only return to my comments on the Prélude above: in the Gigue, Isang Enders often makes his Gagliano cello sound like a viola. The booklet does not mention a violoncello piccolo. He is not using a baroque bow or gut strings (the booklet specifies the brand and type of strings he uses). The articulation and string response are clean, almost aseptic. I do have questions about the intonation of some semiquaver passages, though it is possible that the artist deliberately altered individual notes—I did not investigate this in detail.
I also noted a tendency to apply “belly dynamics” on peak notes (quavers), and exaggerated swelling on peak notes. The performance is not devoid of agogics, yet there is no persistent dance-like swaying.
Total Duration: 28’49”
Rating: 3.5 / 3 / 3 / 3 / 3 / 3.5 / 3 = 3.14
Comment: In his short essay on Bach’s Cello Suites, Isang Enders demonstrates his awareness of the Suites’ importance in Bach’s body of work and in the cello repertoire. Unfortunately his interpretation fails to convey their emotional and expressive content beyond sheer sonority.

David Watkin, 2013
Resonus, ℗/© 2015
Artist: David Watkin (1965 – 2025)
Instrument: Five-string violoncello piccolo by Antonio Amati (1560 – 1649) & Hieronymus Amati (1562 – 1630), Cremona, c.1600; gut strings and baroque bow
Pitch: a’ = 415 Hz
See the Comparison Summary for more information on artist, instrument, recording location etc.
For general comments concerning recording quality and settings, acoustics, as well as the artist’s approach to the Cello Suites see the posting on the Suite No.1 for Cello Solo in G major, BWV 1007.
I. Prélude (4’56”)
David Watkin’s articulation is relatively broad and often quasi-legato. With this, Watkin primarily achieves phrasing through subtle dynamics, thinking in phrases rather than focusing on the individual motif (quaver triplet or half-bar). Sonority is certainly an important objective in this interpretation, even though high notes are often whirring, especially in quaver triplets with two slurred notes.
In bars 81/82, David Watkin accelerates the descent to E almost dramatically, then slows down almost as dramatically on the ascent to the quasi-fermata in the middle of bar 83. This leads to the virtuosic semiquaver cadenza which the listener can just barely follow.
II. Allemande (8’49”)
In terms of timing, David Watkin’s Allemande falls between the viola da gamba performances by Myriam Rignol and Lucile Boulanger. With these two it shares a pace that makes it difficult or impossible for the listener to follow the harmonic progression over larger segments. However, similar to Lucile Boulanger, his playing is rhythmically free in the ornamentation, creatingthe impression of calm, solemn breathing throughout the movement. Here, the rhythmic swaying is even more pronounced and governed by crotchet periods. Apart from the rhythmic freedom, Watkin remains faithful to the notation in Anna Magdalena Bach’s manuscriupt copy. My main quibble is with the slow pace. Otherwise, it is a beautiful, harmonious interpretation.
III. Courante (3’42”)
David Watkin’s interpretation of the Courante almost bursts with energy, joy, and liveliness. The sonority is very colorful. Watkin did not try to smooth out rough edges, such as whirring of strings or passages—especially high notes on the a string—standing out from the flow. While it is certainly not a polished recording, it is a truly enthralling one.
IV. Sarabande (4’59”)
I like the moderate tempo, the general approach, and the basic sonority of the precious Amati violoncello piccolo. However, Watkin’s performance is marred by two related distractions. Both have to do with the frequent upbeat upstrokes. The piece has numerous bars with a crotchet upbeat following half-notes or a dotted half-note. After these long notes, the artist needs to reach the other end of the bow within a short crotchet with a fast bow movement. It is challenging to control the volume of that short note. Unfortunately, in Watkin’s interpretation these notes often stand out from the surrounding notes and frequently end in Nachdrücken, i.e., the bow accelerating toward the end of the note, resulting in an unwanted swelling.
Some may say these are minor defects. However, once these defects are noticed, listeners become fixated on them and can no longer enjoy the music.
V./VI. Gavotte I — Gavotte II — Gavotte I da capo (4’56”)
Gavotte I
This is a beautiful, historically informed performance. It features the characteristic sound of gut strings without excess noise. The articulation avoids rough edges and maintains a nice dance sway. The arpeggio chords are seamlessly integrated into the flow. One might say that the interpretation could show more life and dynamic variation, but this is critique at a very high level.
Gavotte II
As the first Gavotte already features smooth articulation, the gentler second Gavotte doesn’t offer much contrast between the two sister movements. Additionally, the two couplets—the first one with the ostinato voice, and the musette imitation—are perfectly integrated into the movement, adding little or no contrast. This feels like a missed opportunity.
Along with Petr Skalka and Myriam Rignol, David Watkin is among a small group of artists performing the da capo instance of Gavotte I with both repeats.
VII. Gigue (4’14”)
This is an energetic final dance, full of verve, and momentum. The sonority is strong, from the powerful, sometimes grumbling bass to the intensely singing descant, which is occasionally fairly pungent as well. Throughout the piece, one can feel a prominent, dance-like swaying.
Total Duration: 31’35”
Rating: 4 / 4.5 / 4.5 / 4 / 4.5 / 4 / 4.5 = 4.29
Comment: This historically informed performance is highly recommended and close to my very top favorites. Just be careful if you’re allergic to whirring high notes.
Thomas Demenga, 2014
ECM New Series, ℗/© 2017
Artist: Thomas Demenga (*1954, see also Wikipedia)
Instrument: Cello by Giuseppe Guarneri del Gesú (1698 – 1744), Cremona; baroque bow
Pitch: a’ = 392 Hz
See the Comparison Summary for more information on artist, instrument, recording location etc.
For general comments concerning recording quality and settings, acoustics, as well as the artist’s approach to the Cello Suites see the posting on the Suite No.1 for Cello Solo in G major, BWV 1007. Thomas Demenga’s cello is a standard, modernized four-string instrument.
I. Prélude (4’35”)
Apart from the low pitch of a’ = 392 Hz, a key feature of this performance is Thomas Demenga’s clear and detailed articulation. This begins already with the initial bariolage motifs, where the tied note (on the alternate string) is clearly identifiable, sounding almost détaché. In the echo bars, Demenga not only lowers the volume, but also applies light spiccato articulation.
Thomas Demenga’s phrasing and structural clarity in this movement are exemplary. Without disecting the flow into tiny motifs, he achieves this through detailed articulation and dynamics, as well as “speaking” agogics. The fluid, faster-than-average tempo supports this. The entire performance feels effortless and light. The culmination occurs in the soprano register in bars 69 – 73. It feels liberated and effortless, like animal calls in nature. After the peak, a little ornament (an inverted mordent on the last quaver triplet in bar 74) underscores the absence of strain.
The semiquaver cadenza follows a short fermata on the dotted crotchet in bar 83. It is simply astounding how it maintains Klangrede (Harnoncourt, 1983) through all the virtuosic passages. This is definitely one of the best imaginable interpretations of this movement.
II. Allemande (8’13”)
I needed to listen to this performance more than once before I realized what a fantastic interpretation it is. Thomas Demenga often keeps the relative note durations intact within the ornaments (e.g., in the demisemiquaver chain in bar 16). However, the ornaments don’t sound static or overly metrical. In fact, there are many instances where the meter is interpreted freely. Together with articulation, agogics and “speaking” dynamics, the artist creates a strong narrative where every bar and phrase tells a little story. The voices (bass vs. soprano) engage in a lively, expressive and captivating dialog, and despite the moderate tempo, Demenga maintains the tension from the first to the last bar.
III. Courante (3’32”)
The timing of Thomas Demenga’s Courante recording is identical to that of Pieter Wispelwey’s 2012 performance. Apart from their extraordinary musical and technical mastery, the two recordings indeed bear similarities in their general approach to articulation and phrasing. I might simply state that Demenga’s articulation is a little more consequent and strict (even occasionally a tad frugal?). At the same time, Demenga’s playing feels a little more direct in terms of sonority, expression and dynamics. I can’t decide which of the two recordings I prefer. It may depend on my mood or the time of the day. Both are enthralling and fascinating, for sure!
IV. Sarabande (4’52”)
Thomas Demenga presents a beautiful performance of the Sarabande, which is calm, peaceful, and perfectly balanced in sonority and dynamics. There is vibrato, but it is subtle, calm, and never intrusive. Demenga follows the notation, though he does not play every chord note to its full length. His interpretation focuses on the main melody voice, partially accompanied by a second voice, with harmonic support from the low chord notes. Demenga showcases the natural beauty of gut string sonority without overindulging in the beauty of Bach’s harmonies. The articulation is careful and light, never noisy.
Unsurprisingly, Demenga enriches the performance with exquisite, natural ornaments. These are mostly in the repeats and typically simple, such as turns, or transition notes filling a third interval in a melody. In short, it is an interpretation in perfect harmony and naturalness, with beautiful aesthetics without unnecessary perfection.
V./VI. Gavotte I — Gavotte II — Gavotte I da capo (3’10”)
Gavotte I
Thomas Demenga’s interpretation of the first Gavotte highlights the piece’s rustic aspects and internal contrasts. There are sonorous and powerful, yet not exaggerated, chords; smooth legato quavers next to terse staccato with “bite”, and gut string sonority with the occasional whirring. There is a strong, but heavy dance sway, but also elegant jeu inégal in bar 19. The interpretation is rich and beautiful. It’s unfortunate the second part is not repeated, but OK, there is the da capo…
Gavotte II
The second Gavotte introduces more contrasts. It begins softly, with subtle staccato crotchets, and even the two arpeggio chords set gentle accents. In the first couplet, Demenga switches to a slower pace, turning the ostinato accompaniment into a heavy peasant dance. The second couplet is also not loud, but rather a broad, melodious legato that starts slightly slower and gradually picks up momentum. Demenga enriches this pastoral musette with inverted mordents on the top notes of the second part (bars 17 and 18).
As in the first Gavotte, Demenga unfortunately omits the second repeat. Was this out of fear that the rustic character of the Gavottes would become too dominant in the Suite?
VII. Gigue (4’15”)
This movement is another masterpiece from Thomas Demenga’s hands. It is enthralling, withan irresistible drive throughout. Nothing is rushed, yet the tension never diminishes. Rather than disrupting the flow, chords propel it forward. Needless to say that Demenga enriches the performance with numerous personal ornaments that are seamlessly integrated. These adornments aren’t just limited to the repeats: bars 5/6 and 37/38 are repeated in the subsequent bars 7/8 and 39/40. Some artists perform the latter as echoes. Demenga marks the repeat bars with an inverted mordent on the first note in each quaver triplet.
One observation: in both passes, the first quaver in bar 35 (G) does not sound. This “hiccup” was not corrected in the recording. Interestingly, the same thing happens in Pablo Casals’ recording. I suspect that on four-string instruments this note (empty G string between f’ and g’) is difficult to integrate into the musical flow. Attempting to “fix” it could have adverse consequences, so it was likely deemed not worth the effort. One devious thought, though: that critical note between huge jumps can stand out oddly if played properly, so maybe some artists felt it is better to leave that tone to the listener’s imagination?
Total Duration: 28’35”
Rating: 5 / 5 / 5 / 5 / 4.5 / 4.5 / 5 = 4.86
Comment: This is clearly one of my top favorites and highly recommended. It is excellent and a pleasure to listen to. It offers highly inventive, original, and personal choices, both in ornamentation and general approach (articulation, phrasing, etc.).
Marianne Dumas, 2016
Urania Records, ℗/© 2018
Artist: Marianne Dumas
Instrument: Five-string baroque cello by Johannes Löscher, Cologne, Germany; gut strings and baroque bow
Pitch: a’ = 415 Hz
See the Comparison Summary for more information on artist, instrument, recording location etc.
For general comments concerning recording quality and settings, acoustics, as well as the artist’s approach to the Cello Suites see the posting on the Suite No.1 for Cello Solo in G major, BWV 1007.
I. Prélude (4’59”)
The Prélude leaves a mixed impression: on the surface, Marianne Dumas forms broad, harmonious phrases. However, there is little structuring and very little time to “breathe”, just an endless stream of quaver triplets. The agogics remain minimal, apart from the occasional very slight acceleration.
The articulation feels very legato and smooth, to the point where the string change in the tied notes in the bariolage motifs becomes nearly inaudible. Didn’t Bach use bariolage to create a specific sonic effect? Here, these motifs often sound like crotchet plus quaver pairs. Where the last note involves jumping up by a sixth or an octave, it often receives an excessive accent, making it feel like a syncope.
Some of the echo effects (p / f) also appear to be smoothed out. Finally, in the top range (around bar 70), the intonation is occasionally less than perfect. In the virtuosic semiquaver segment (bars 83 – 89), the articulation remains clean, though the performance appears to be pushed to its technical limits.
II. Allemande (8’19”)
Sadly, this interpretation is not enjoyable to listen to. Not only is the tempo on the slow side, but the execution of the ornamented line is overly metrical, scholarly, and static. There is a crescendo on most, if not all, of the longer notes, such as quavers and crotchets. Once listeners are aware of this, it becomes obnoxious.
III. Courante (4’13”)
Marianne Dumas’ performance of the Courante is the slowest of the cello recordings, slightly faster than Myriam Rignol’s interpretation on the viola da gamba. The tempo is not the primary issue, though, nor are the frequent whirring tones. I miss a dance-like sway, and primarily, the articulation appears negligent—as if the artist could not decide whether to play the non-slurred notes staccato / spiccato, or with broad détaché strokes.
IV. Sarabande (4’22”)
In my listening sequence from slow to fast, Marianne Dumas’ interpretation of the Sarabande is the first to use a fluid tempo. It is faster than Bruno Philippe’s 2021 performance and Jean-Guihen Queyeras’ 2007 and 2023 recordings. Despite these favorable conditions, Marianne Dumas’ interpretation is flawed by its quasi-legato playing, the Nachdrücken and persistent swelling on every note. These flaws obscure the meter and make difficult to enjoy the recording.
V./VI. Gavotte I — Gavotte II — Gavotte I da capo (4’44”)
Gavotte I
Marianne Dumas’ performance of the first Gavotte is one of the slowest in the comparison. Rhythmically, she follows the alla breve meter (split time, ₵). However, why does every arpeggio chord end with a swelling note? In addition to the arpeggios there are other dynamic outbursts that feel uncontrolled. Additionally, the crotchet following an arpeggio chord is often slightly late and short. Is this meant to be jeu inégal? This recording makes me question whether the artist just wanted to sound different or if the outcome is an unfortunate consequence of the underhand bow hold.
Gavotte II
The dynamics are more controlled than in the first Gavotte, though there are still some odd swellings, most prominently on the half note in bar 12. The tempo is better in this Gavotte, but I’m unhappy with the articulation of the crotchets in the ritornello. It lacks bite. With this, the rhythm feels washed out, superficial, and badly defined.
VII. Gigue (4’04”)
Marianne Dumas’ tempo in the Gigue is close to Steven Isserlis’: above average, but not extraordinarily fast. Yet, her performance leaves the impression that the artist was in a hurry. There is a constant, irritating push forward, and the articulation within motifs is rushed and superficial. Many semiquaver passages are mangled.
Total Duration: 30’40”
Rating: 3 / 2 / 2.5 / 2 / 2 / 2.5 / 2.5 = 2.36
Comment: This recording illustrates the impact of the underhand bow hold on Bach’s Cello Suites. However, it fails to show any advantages of this technique; rather, it highlights its disadvantages and shortcomings. Contrary to what the CD title might suggest, the underhand bow hold was certainly not the only or main technique used during Bach’s time.
Kim Kashkashian, 2017 — Viola
ECM New Series, ℗/© 2018
Artist: Kim Kashkashian (*1952, see also Wikipedia)
Instrument: Five-string viola by Francesco Bissolotti (1929 – 2019), Cremona, 1989
See the Comparison Summary for more information on artist, instrument, recording location etc.
For general comments concerning recording quality and settings, acoustics, as well as the artist’s approach to the Cello Suites see the posting on the Suite No.1 for Cello Solo in G major, BWV 1007.
I. Prélude (5’01”)
At the level of individual notes, Kim Kashkashian’s articulation in the Prélude bears similarities to Pierre Fournier’s: there is elasticity and a springy accent in every note. Unlike Fournier, though, Kim Kashkashian shapes every phrase with agogics, making her interpretation far more lively and less monotonous and relentless.
Unfortunately, the artist has an odd tendency to insert a little pause between phrases, typically at the bar line. In these instances, she ends a phrase with an upward bow, then lifts the bow to give the next phrase a fresh (down-bow) start. While this may add structural clarity, it disrupts the flow, making it appear irregular and fragmenting the movement.
Lastly, Bach made use of the soprano register of the cello, extending it up to g”. When performed on a viola, the piece is transposed up by an octave. This means that the top of the range in the Prélude reaches up to g”’, which is outside the range of the human voice. In these high registers, the tone of the instrument is rather thin and immaterial, like a falsetto voice (implying a little falsehood or deception), as opposed to the fully engaged (and engaging) soprano voice of the cello’s top register.
II. Allemande (7’29”)
Kim Kashkashian’s tempo is very close to those of Pablo Casals and Emmanuelle Bertrand. At its core, this is a traditional (though not necessarily romantic) interpretation, as indicated by the controlled and mostly restricted, non-intrusive use of vibrato. As with the other movements (and suites), the upward transposition by an octave shifts the perception, moving the ornamented voice into the high soprano register while giving extra focus to the bass, or rather, the baritone/tenor register.
While the above should amplify the ornamental character of the top voice, that benefit is partly offset by the restricted agogics and the absence of real Klangrede (Harnoncourt, 1983). Chains of identical note values (semiquavers or demisemiquavers) tend to be rather linear. When Bach indicates acceleration within a motif by switching to smaller notes, e.g., from semiquavers to demisemiquavers, the acceleration often does not appear harmonious.
I’m also not happy with some of the articulation choices. Examples are the omission of the tie at the beginning of bar 2 and the odd falling arpeggio in the first pass of bar 4. I primarily see that element that as useful for complex polyphonic passages, such as in a three- or four-part fugue. One may also question some of the artist’s extra ornaments.
III. Courante (4’02”)
I like the tempo and articulation in this interpretation. However, the viola may not be the ideal instrument for this movement, as it centers on the tenor register (which cannot compete with the cello’s bass register) while moving large parts of the piece into the thinner soprano register. My main reservation is that there is too much emphasis on the first note in most bars, which makes some of the interpretation feel heavy. At the same time, phrase highlights and endings are often slightly broadened, causing subtle hiccups that tend to break the regularity of the dance rhythm.
IV. Sarabande (4’17”)
Kim Kashkashian performs the Sarabande with careful articulation. Despite a fluid tempo similar to those of to Pablo Casals and Petr Skalka’, her interpretation feels reflective and contemplative. Unfortunately, the prominent vibrato adds a romantic note that does not fit the baroque composition. As with the Courante, the piece does not benefit from upward octave shift: the melody voice feels lonely because the chords are mostly short arpeggios that could just as well come from a soft plucked instrument. They can’t provide a sonic foundation for the melody.
The performance also fails to offer a persistent 3/2 dance sway, and the artist’s added ornamentation in the repeats further obscures the underlying 3/2 meter.
V./VI. Gavotte I — Gavotte II — Gavotte I da capo (5’02”)
Gavotte I
Throughout the Gavottes, Kim Kashkashian pays close attention to her articulation. Every detail seems carefully crafted. However, her excessive focus on the arpeggios causes the chords to take up extra time. This disrupts the rhythm and prevents consistent dance swaying. In the repeats, the artist adds numerous ornaments. This is a welcome feature, especially in paired movements where the first movement appears twice—even three times with the inclusion of the repeats. I should mention, though, that Kashkashian’s ornaments are rather unconventional in kind and placement. They are probably not to every listener’s taste.
Gavotte II
The above remarks about the extra ornaments also apply to the second Gavotte. Additionally, in the ritornello, Kim Kashkashian made the questionable decision to add a strong, broad accent to the third crotchet in the two bars with four crotchets. This feels odd and unnecessary—is it meant to be humorous? The accent appears twelve times in total, making it highly idiosyncratic in an otherwise decent interpretation.
VII. Gigue (4’47”)
Kim Kashkashian mostly plays with verve and determination, though with a few quirks in the articulation. To me, not all of her decisions on where to play détaché with percussive or mellow articulation, and where to play legato make sense. One example is in bars 5 – 8, where the transition from the upbeat quaver to the subsequent slurred quaver pair often feels oddly soft and vague.
More importantly, the musical flow lacks dance character, as well as tempo and rhythmic continuity. This is partly due to the tiny pauses caused by large jumps and the execution of three- and four-string chords.
Total Duration: 30’38”
Rating: 3 / 3.5 / 3.5 / 3.5 / 3.5 / 3.5 / 3 = 3.36
Comment: Kim Kashkashian’s interpretation does not convince me that transposing this suite up by an octave suits the composition, nor that playing it on a viola is a good idea. Bach knew exactly what the cello could do and how to exploit its unique qualities. This makes transferring the piece to another instrument a real challenge.

Sergey Malov, 2018 — Violoncello da spalla
Sony / Solo Musica, ℗/© 2020
Artist: Sergey Malov (*1983, see also Wikipedia)
Instrument: Five-string Violoncello da spalla by Dmitry Badiarov (*1969), Den Haag, The Netherlands; baroque bow
See the Comparison Summary for more information on artist, instrument, recording location etc.
For general comments concerning recording quality and settings, acoustics, as well as the artist’s approach to the Cello Suites see the posting on the Suite No.1 for Cello Solo in G major, BWV 1007. With rare exceptions (first repeats in Sarabande and Gavotte II) Sergey Malov leaves out all repeats.
I. Prélude (3’59”)
Given his interpretations of the preceding Cello Suites it is no surprise that Sergey Malov delivers the fastest Prélude performance. The artist certainly has the technical ability and stamina to perform this movement at this pace. His articulation is clear, detailed, and careful. See below for some minor reservations. Compared to a cello, his instrument has an advantage in the soprano register because it is smaller than a typical violoncello piccolo. Here, this register sounds particularly clear and intense. Conversely, the instrument has a slight weakness in the bass register, where it cannot compete with the sound of a full-size cello or also some of the violoncello piccolo instruments.
I have some minor quibbles: the string transition in the bariolage motifs is often hard to hear. Also, the intonation is occasionally slightly impure. For the semiquaver cadenza, the tempo is a little excessive. To me, such an extroverted, virtuosic segment seems out of place in the context of the Cello Suites.
Extra ornaments are rarely added to this movement. Malov adds a small, inconspicuous one around the middle of the movement. After the cadenza, though, starting with the last of the arpeggio chords, Malov adds several ornaments that I don’t want to criticize. They are nice, fitting, and inventive, but hardly a necessity.
II. Allemande (3’04”)
Sergey Malov’s performance of the Allemande is substantially faster than Vito Paternoster’s rendition, making it the fastest interpretation in this comparison. At this pace, the ornaments undoubtedly appear as adornments, not as melody in themselves. However, just as with Paternoster, I fail to sense the underlying 4/4 meter, let alone a 4/4 dance sway.
In bar 8 (the last bar in the first part), Malov adds several chords, harmonizing Bach’s composition. These additions are clearly recognizable as the artist’s own. Even if they are not properly “in style”, I would not object to such additions as long as they occur in a repeat. Here, however, the repeat is omitted, so the listener never gets to hear Bach’s original composition. Another added chord appears on the second crotchet period (g) in bar 13. This chord much more integrated and properly “in style”.
III. Courante (1’44”)
Unsurprisingly, Sergey Malov presents one of the fastest Courantes in this comparison. His performance is faster than those of Thomas Demenga and Pieter Wispelwey in 2012. Malov is an artist with excellent technical skills. He seems to master the fast tempo of the Courante effortlessly, even allowing him to insert an inverted mordent every now and then. Overall, his performance does not feel rushed. However, the tempo is rather uneven, accelerating regularly for the semiquaver passages and producing strong “rhythmic and dynamic waves” that prevent a persistent dance feeling. The performance is joyful and fun, but it is difficult to imagine dancing to this interpretation.
IV. Sarabande (2’31”)
After Vito Paternoster’s recording, this is the fastest Sarabande in the comparison. With its strong emphasis on half-note beats in 3/2 meter, Malov’s recording resembles Anner Bylsma’s performance from 1979. Even though it is nowhere near Bylsma’s rigid, formal rhythm, the half-note beats still feel heavy and too prominent. Malov also plays mostly with vibrato. It is not too intrusive, but a tad nervous. Does the violoncello da spalla lead to faster vibrato than a cello?
Throughout the Cello Suites, Malov unfortunately omits almost all repeats. This Sarabande is an exception, in that the eight bars of the first part are indeed repeated. That repeat is adorned with a set of beautiful and inventive ornaments. Some of these ornaments are quite elaborate. They are fioriture rather than simple ornaments. I understand if some find them overdone or contrived, but I like and enjoy them. I think they fit well and enrich the piece. The second repeat is still missing, though.
V./VI. Gavotte I — Gavotte II — Gavotte I da capo (2’19”)
Gavotte I
It feels as if Sergey Malov intended to highlight the folksy character of the Gavotte. He left the piece unpolished, seemingly not trying to hide or avoid the whirring of the upper strings, especially on peak notes and endings. The arpeggio chords are not rough or coarse, but often feel like sonorous eruptions nonetheless. Despite its rustic appearance, the outcome is coherent and attractive.
I can’t avoid my usual grievance with this recording—neither of the repeats is performed. This is particularly unfortunate with such small movements. One might argue that the da capo is still present for the first Gavotte. However, that does not address the initial encounter with this music.
Gavotte II
The above remarks also apply to Gavotte II. I particularly like the light character of the ritornello and the first couplet with their capricious staccato crotchets. Some might argue that the musette’s rustic character is exaggerated, especially in the second half of the couplet, when the bagpipe imitation becomes loud and wild. For once, though, I don’t see this as negative at all. I should mention that the first part of the piece is repeated, probably because the ritornello is only four bars long.
VII. Gigue (1’52”)
Sergey Malov once again delivers the fastest performance of a movement, equaling Anner Bylsma’s first recording from 1979. The tempo itself does not feel excessively fast. However, the performance definitely feels rushed within motifs and short figures. A few notes even fall through the cracks. Overall, the articulation is clear and detailed. Still, the performance leaves an impression of superficiality. This may be compounded by the fast pace that does not allow enough time for agogics and expression at the level of motifs.
Total Duration: 15’29”
Rating: 4 / 4 / 4.5 / 4.5 / 4.5 / 4.5 / 4.5 = 4.36
Comment: This is an interesting recording by an artist with superb technical abilities. I can recommend it with some reservation. If only the artist wasn’t so often focused on being fast, a quality that is rarely a criterion for such music. Also, omitting most repeats is essentially unforgivable and raises doubts about the seriousness of the recording.
Emmanuelle Bertrand, 2019
Harmonia mundi, ℗/© 2019
Artist: Emmanuelle Bertrand (*1973)
Instrument: Carlo Annibale Tononi (1675 – 1730), Venice, early 18th century; gut strings and baroque bow
Pitch: a’ = 415 Hz
See the Comparison Summary for more information on artist, instrument, recording location etc.
For general comments concerning recording quality and settings, acoustics, as well as the artist’s approach to the Cello Suites see the posting on the Suite No.1 for Cello Solo in G major, BWV 1007. Emmanuelle Bertrand’s cello is a standard, modernized four-string instrument, equipped with gut strings.
I. Prélude (4’25”)
This is a natural, harmonious performance at a fluid tempo. Emmanuelle Bertrand observes Bach’s slurs. Her articulation is generally clean, typically legato or broad détaché. The bow rarely leaves the strings, and there is no spiccato or similar bowing technique. She maintains a continuous flow and avoids showy effects. The sonority is beautiful and resonant. Occasionally, the artist tends to “swallow” the middle note in quaver triplets. There is phrasing in long arches, but occasionally, I wished for more time to breathe in very long phrases and maybe some extra Klangrede (Harnoncourt, 1983) at the level of bars and motifs.
The semiquaver cadenza is fast, virtuosic, and controlled, but it occasionally lacks rhythmic clarity. The second part of the cadenza begins with a return to the initial bariolage motif. Bars 90 and 91, as well as 92 and 93, form echo pairs. In the sources, bars 90 and 91 end on a’, while the second pair is downshifted by a fifth. Emmanuelle Bertrand plays bar 90 as written, but plays the last note in bar 91 as g’. I concede that Anna Magdalena Bach’s manuscript copy is slightly ambiguous at this point. However, it seems illogical to “break the echo sequence”, given that in all other instances, the echo is an exact replica of the preceding bar.
II. Allemande (7’31”)
In the Allemande, Emmanuelle Bertrand’s timing is identical to Casals’ interpretation. However, the two performances could hardly be more different. One could characterize her performance as gentle, amiable, and soft. One component of this is the tone, which is soft, restrained, and mellow. The descant on this four-string instrument often has a slightly immaterial, falsetto-like quality.
The other component of the mellowness lies in articulation, agogics, and rhythm. Emmanuelle Bertrand softens rhythmic contours by subtly broadening hemidemisemiquaver figures, for example. Overall, the interpretation feels introverted and restrained.
Then, there’s the ornamentation. The artist adds a fair number of additional ornaments. With the exception of the curly descent in the last part of bar 18 (repeat only), these are simple, such as trills and inverted mordents, and the occasional, subtle jeu inégal. Considering Bach’s rich ornamentation, these should not be necessary. The extra ornaments make the built-in ornamentation appear as melodic elements. This obscures the underlying 4/4 meter.
III. Courante (3’39”)
This is a natural and harmonious interpretation. The tempo is adequate for a Courante. However, the artist may be operating at her technical limits, as there is a small mishap in the first pass of bar 30. There are also numerous minor imperfections, such as poorly defined semiquavers, especially in the second repeat. Is the fast tempo worth the risk?
IV. Sarabande (5’40”)
Emmanuelle Bertrand’s tempo is a little faster than Pieter Wispelwey’s 2012 interpretation. While it is one of the slowest performances, it does not repeat the flaws in Pierre Fournier’s interpretation. Sadly, however, the artist added unnecessary vibrato, possibly in an attempt to fill the long, slow melodies with expression. There is also a notable tendency toward “belly notes” and Nachdrücken. Overall the contrast to Wispelwey’s 2012 recording is striking—and not in favor of Bertrand’s interpretation.
V./VI. Gavotte I — Gavotte II — Gavotte I da capo (4’16”)
Gavotte I
The initial bars of the first Gavotte feel light and fluid, though the articulation soon becomes rather broad, heavy, and overengaged. The rhythmic continuity is reasonable, but the sense of dance is lacking.
Gavotte II
I like Emmanuelle Bertrand’s approach to the second Gavotte in general. It is gentler and softer than its sister movement and does not exaggerate the folksy aspects of the piece. My main quibble is with the articulation, which is often rather mellow and not really light. It feels as if the artist could not decide between broad détaché and staccato articulation. This leaves the listener in limbo.
VII. Gigue (4’23”)
This is an enthralling performance full of verve and momentum. I have a few quibbles, though. Emmanuelle Bertrand splits some of the three- and four-string arpeggio chords into two consecutive parts, which breaks the rhythm and flow. Examples can be found in bars 9, 11, 13, 14, 16, 21, and 22 of the first part. However, before criticizing one should keep in mind that the instrument is a regular four-string cello, which may force the artist either to omit a note in such chords, or to split the chord and perform a position shift with the left hand. It seems as if Emmanuelle Bertrand decided to play all the notes in the chords, which disrupts the flow.
In the second part, bars 57 – 59 feel slightly rushed. Finally, the reverberation (church acoustics) is at a level where it occasionally becomes irritating.
Total Duration: 29’54”
Rating: 4 / 3.5 / 3.5 / 3 / 3 / 3.5 / 3.5 = 3.43
Comment: Cello Suite No.6 may not be her strongest or most convincing performance in this series, though it is probably the most challenging of the Suites. Nevertheless, I rate the performance as engaging and the overall experience as positive.

Juris Teichmanis, 2019
Decurio, ℗/© 2019
Artist: Juris Teichmanis (*1966)
Instrument: Five-string violoncello piccolo from Southern Germany, c.1750; gut strings and baroque bow
Pitch: a’ = 400 Hz
See the Comparison Summary for more information on artist, instrument, recording location etc.
For general comments concerning recording quality and settings, acoustics, as well as the artist’s approach to the Cello Suites see the posting on the Suite No.1 for Cello Solo in G major, BWV 1007.
I. Prélude (4’55”)
While I appreciate the effort to return to gut strings and historic sonorities, does the sound really have to be so crude and often scratchy? I’m not expecting sterile perfection in sound and articulation, but this really limits the listening pleasure, as does the often careless intonation.
II. Allemande (8’21”)
The combination of a slow tempo and overly metrical execution of the ornamented melody line makes this performance feel celebrated, drawn out, and often static. The listener loses track of any overall development.
III. Courante (4’06”)
This is one of the better movements in Juris Teichmanis’ interpretation. It is careful and detailed in agogics and articulation, and devoid of major inconsequences in the slurring. This recording made me realize that inconsequential slurring (as found in other interpretations) is primarily a distraction, not an enrichment. The tempo is moderate yet allows for a decent dance sway.
IV. Sarabande (5’01”)
Juris Teichmanis’ tempo is very close to Pablo de Naverán’s. As with the latter, I don’t really feel “at home” in this interpretation, though for different reasons. Teichmanis’ vibrato is not nervous, but is used more frequently and consistently. More importantly, the arpeggio chords are rather time-consuming and often noisy. Additionally, the sound of the e’ string tends to be stingy, to stand out excessively, making it feel like poorly controlled dynamics. The chords and irregular dynamics obscure the phrasing and any rhythmic structure. They distract from enjoying the beauty of Bach’s music.
V./VI. Gavotte I — Gavotte II — Gavotte I da capo (4’33”)
Gavotte I
This performance suffers from rhythmic disruption due to the attempt to incorporate arpeggio chords into the rhythmic flow. Additionally, the chords are also often noisy and scratchy, and there is no sustained sense of dance.
Gavotte II
In most interpretations, the second Gavotte is lighter and faster. However, in Juris Teichmanis’ performance, it is slower than Gavotte I, to the point that it lacks the lightness of a dance and sounds uninteresting, static, and sluggish.
VII. Gigue (4’28”)
This interpretation has its good moments, such as the motifs with slurred quavers in bars 5 – 8 and 37 – 40, where the the articulation is light and the dynamics differentiated. Unfortunately, these moments are undermined in segments with détaché quavers which sound overly square and rigid, defeating any sense of dance, let alone the fun of a last dance. Also, many of the semiquaver motifs feel almost tortured. I don’t claim the movement is easy to play (it isn’t), but demonstrating this does not add value for the listener.
Total Duration: 31’23”
Rating: 2.5 / 3 / 4 / 3 / 3 / 3 / 2.5 = 3.00
Comment: Does the artist intend to demonstrate that his performance is historically informed? If so, this recording fails to achieve that. I think that a performance can be HIP without demonstrating that performances in Bach’s time were (presumably) far from the perfection of today’s digital recordings.
Benedict Kloeckner, 2020
Brilliant Classics, ℗/© 2021
Artist: Benedict Kloeckner (*1989, see also Wikipedia)
Instrument: Francesco Rugeri (c.1628 – 1698), Cremona, c.1690
See the Comparison Summary for more information on artist, instrument, recording location etc.
For general comments concerning recording quality and settings, acoustics, as well as the artist’s approach to the Cello Suites see the posting on the Suite No.1 for Cello Solo in G major, BWV 1007. Benedikt Kloeckner’s cello is a standard, modernized four-string instrument.
I. Prélude (4’31”)
Bach writes all bariolage motifs with a tie connecting the first two notes. These are not just two tied quavers, but the idea is that switching to an alternate string gives these notes their individual character and makes them identifiable. Notably, Benedikt Kloeckner disregards these ties, playing most bariolage motifs with a spiccato-like articulation. Often, judging from the sonority, the tied notes could have been played on the same string. In “ordinary” quaver sequences or phrases, the artist mostly follows the slurs in the notation.
Other quibbles with this interpretation include the occasional tendency to accelerate or push the pace. The effect is subtle, but enough to make the listener feel as if the artist was in a hurry to finish the movement. A subtle vibrato on an occasional long note might be acceptable. However, Kloeckner often uses vibrato on the peak quaver in some phrases. To me, this sounds unnecessary and adds no value to a largely vibrato-less performance.
II. Allemande (7’44”)
Benedikt Kloeckner’s interpretation, played at a tempo slightly above average, is technically perfect in terms of articulation, clarity, and intonation, with detailed and careful dynamics. Long notes are played with subtle unobtrusive vibrato.
There is even more perfection, to the point where it becomes excessive. Kloeckner strives to maintain the proper relative duration of every note, from crotchets down to semihemidemisemiquavers (1/256th). Remarkably, he largely achieves this without sounding mechanical. The performance does not sound robotic. Still, unsurprisingly, the music remains devoid of expression and emotion. There is little, if any, life in this interpretation.
III. Courante (3’27”)
Benedikt Kloeckner’s Courante is one of the fastest in this comparison, even faster than Sergey Malov’s. My impression is that the tempo is pushed beyond its limits. While the semiquavers are mostly articulated properly, some remain ill-defined in terms of sonority and intonation. Additionally, the bow touches neighboring strings in many semiquaver passages. The resulting bariolage effect may be intentional. However, this is not indicated in the notation, and it does not contribute favorably to the listening experience.
IV. Sarabande (4’54”)
This is a carefully and cleanly articulated modern performance. Benedikt Kloeckner uses a continuous vibrato throughout. Fortunately, it is neither nervous nor overly intrusive or strong enough to affect the intonation. Rather, it is a calm, harmonious swaying, which is OK, as the artist does not intend to present a HIP performance. Kloeckner carefully controls the dynamics and avoids idiosyncrasies in the articulation. The playing is beautiful overall, even though it does not reach the emotional and expressive depth of the top HIP performances.
V./VI. Gavotte I — Gavotte II — Gavotte I da capo (4’08”)
Gavotte I
The first Gavotte feels rather metrical and static as a dance. One can sense the large phrases, but agogics, or life in general, are missing at the level of motifs. Nevertheless, the performance is technically clean, with clear and detailed articulation. Is the composition a little unwieldy, or did the artist intend to depict this piece as a formal court dance, perhaps as a caricature?
Gavotte II
The second Gavotte contrasts with its intimacy and playfulness. Benedict Kloeckner uses subtle jeu inégal in the quaver motifs to make the music sway. After the double bar, the first couplet is a tad slower, feeling comfy and relaxed. The two voices are perfectly balanced. The second couplet, a musette, is notably faster. This makes that segment feel slightly odd and out of context. Did the artist fail to integrate the musette style into the tempo of the Gavotte?
VII. Gigue (4’13”)
In the Gigue, Benedikt Kloeckner’s articulation of the détaché quavers seems a little too concise. On the other hand, splitting several three- and four-string arpeggio chords into two parts often disrupts the rhythm and flow. The same happens when the artist excessively broadens key notes that he wants to highlight. As a result, there is very little, if any, persistent dance feeling in this movement. The movement also lacks natural agogics. Is the interpretation a tad too intellectual?
Total Duration: 28’57”
Rating: 4 / 3.5 / 3.5 / 4.5 / 4 / 4 / 3.5 = 3.86
Comment: Benedikt Kloeckner offers a technically superb interpretation, clearly the result of careful thought and consideration, with highlights such as the Sarabande. Overall, though, I sense a little too much intellect and not enough spontaneity and expression—agogics, in particular.
Benedict Kloeckner’s Extra for the Suite in D major
As outlined in the Comparison Summary, Benedict Kloeckner complemented each of the Suites by adding a contemporary piece that he commissioned himself. In the case of the Cello Suite No.6 in D major, this is a short composition by Dai Fujikura (*1977).
The Composer, Dai Fujikura
Dai Fujikura (*1977, see also Wikipedia) was born in Osaka, Japan. At age 15, he moved to London to study music studies at the Dover College. Initially, he intended to compose music for cinema. While studying at the Trinity College of Music, he discovered the works of Pierre Boulez (1925 – 2016), György Ligeti (1923 – 2006), and Tōru Takemitsu (1930 – 1996). These encounters, coupled with his knowledge of cinematography, helped him establish himself as a contemporary composer. His music has been performed by numerous artists and ensembles, including the London Sinfonietta.
Fujikura’s oeuvre, works composed from 2005 onward, includes two operas, orchestral and ensemble works, and chamber music.
The Work: “Sweet Sweets”
The 4-minute (3’51”) solo piece that Benedict Kloeckner commissioned is “Sweet Sweets”. In the booklet text (© Dai Fujikura), the composer states “Dai Fujikura and Benedict met the first time at the Salzburg „Dialoge” festival, in which Benedict performed Dais Cello concerto. „Sweet Sweets” is inspired by several Bach Suites and quotes them in a subtle way, developing motivic material into new fascinating sound landscapes oscillating between the old and the new musical world. It ends with a touching coda, fading in high flageolet double stops, real „sounds of light”.“
How Does it Sound?
In most of the complementary pieces included in Benedikt Kloeckner’s recording, the connection to the associated Cello Suite is weak at best. That’s different here: a large part of “Sweet Sweets” centers around the core motif from the Prélude of the Suite No.6 in D major, harmonically altered and further evolving through a “visiting” second voice, with momentary, very high flageolet interjections.
There are longer interjections referring to other Bach Suites—some are easily recognizable, though never quoting Bach verbatim. The clearest example is the opening phrase from the Prélude of the Suite No.3 in C major. References to other Suites consist of short motifs or motif sequences, or harmonic progressions from slow movements. I won’t try analyzing it all here.
In summary, of all the complementary pieces, this one is the most impressive. It is beautiful, interesting, expressive, and harmonious (and occasionally mildly dissonant). The coda adds a melancholic, longing note, providing a very touching conclusion, indeed. “Sweet Sweets” is a little gem, a small masterpiece.
Myriam Rignol, 2020 — Viola da gamba
Château de Versailles, ℗ 2020 / © 2021
Artist: Myriam Rignol (*1988, see also Wikipedia)
Instrument: Viola da gamba (bass viol)
Pitch: a’ = 400 Hz, transposed to C major
See the Comparison Summary for more information on artist, instrument, recording location etc.
For general comments concerning recording quality and settings, acoustics, as well as the artist’s approach to the Cello Suites see the posting on the Suite No.1 for Cello Solo in G major, BWV 1007.
I. Prélude (4’41”)
The timing of Myriam Rignol’s performance is identical to that of Anner Bylsma’s 1979 recording. Her interpretation feels fluid and harmonious. Unfortunately, the string change in some of the bariolage motifs is barely audible. However, that’s a minor point.
The primary impression from this recording is the instrument’s big, dark, and full-bodied sonority. This is partly due to the low pitch of a’ = 400 Hz combined with the transposition to C major (equivalent to D major on an instrument tuned at a pitch of a’ = 356 Hz)—more than three-quarters of a tone lower than the two lowest cello recordings (Pieter Wispelwey 2012 and Thomas Demenga) at a pitch of a’ = 392 Hz. The instrument’s abundant resonances contribute to the rich, enveloping soundscape of the recording. The underhand bow hold on the viola da gamba affects articulation, as it does not favor light articulations, such as spiccato.
My main quibble is that the détaché articulation throughout bars 85 and 86 of the semiquaver cadenza makes this segment sound unnecessarily wild and unruly. There are other textual alterations caused by the adaptation for the seven-string viola da gamba. Most of these are hardly noticeable. Others, however, are favorable, such as the octave-downshift of the first quaver (A, or rather G in this performance) in bars 70 – 74, which sounds like a drone or a drumbeat marking the first note in these bars.
II. Allemande (9’24”)
Myriam Rignol’s interpretation of the Allemande is very slow, though not quite as much as Pablo de Naverán’s, let alone Mstislav Rostropovich’s. Unsurprisingly, at this pace, the listener fails to “connect the dots”, i.e., to follow the harmonic progression and the underlying melodic component. The performance is definitely too slow. However, at least Rignol doesn’t plod mechanically through the ornamentation like Rostropovich does. Rather, most demisemiquaver garlands are flexible enough to feel like true ornaments, little fioriture linking the adjacent chords or key notes.
This performance shows that setting the tempo to allow for clean and comfortable execution of the smallest note values—in this case, semihemidemisemiquavers—is not enough. It makes the occasional uniform chain of semiquavers or demisemiquavers sound static, causing the tension to drop and the flow to stop on longer notes, such as quavers and crotchets. The artist’s attempt to bring these longer notes to life using dynamic shaping and the occasional subtle flattement rarely leads to moderate but odd dynamic outbursts.
A flexible rhythmic interpretation of the ornamentation is intended and desirable, not a deviation from the text. Myriam Rignol remains as faithful to the notation in Anna Magdalena Bach’s manuscript copy as most cello performances. The addition of a chord on the first beat of bar 8 is a welcome exception.
III. Courante (4’30”)
In the Courante, Myriam Rignol articulates carefully and clearly, producing full and warm sonority throughout. My main reservation is that the slurring is often inconsequential. In most instances, the two semiquavers in the main motif appear slurred to the following quaver, as suggested by the Neue Bach-Ausgabe (Eppstein, 1988). Sometimes, however, Rignol extends the slur to the following quaver. One example is in bar 3. Most quavers are played staccato; however, in bar 7, the first and last pair of quavers are played legato.
Occasionally, the highlighting of peak notes seems slightly exaggerated. Myriam Rignol’s tempo is moderate, which suits the careful articulation. Around the climax and in the closing bars of either part, the artist gradually broadens the pace, as if to highlight these segments. However, this also momentarily causes the performance to lose momentum.
IV. Sarabande (5’21”)
The timing of the viola da gamba recordings in this comparison, including those by Paolo Pandolfo and Lucile Boulanger, is nearly identical. In much of his recording, Pandolfo alters and expands Bach’s notation, exploiting the viol’s characteristics—though not in the Sarabande. Lucile Boulanger’s partial recording does what one might expect Pandolfo to do and more. In contrast, Myriam Rignol’s performance of the Sarabande stays closest to Bach’s score, except for transposing the suite down a tone to C major.
Myriam Rignol’s interpretation does not feel like a lament. Rather, it creates a calm, serene and relaxed atmosphere. The articulation is light and the melody is peaceful and unhurried. Myriam Rignol plays the chords as short arpeggios, keeping the focus on the melody. These arpeggios evoke the image of a pastoral scene with a singer accompanied by a lute or a harp. Beautiful and soothing!
V./VI. Gavotte I — Gavotte II — Gavotte I da capo (5’22”)
Gavotte I
In my listening sequence from slow to fast performances, this is the fifth recording. From the tempo alone it is the first one that feels close to normal, i.e., not overly heavy or even clumsy. Myriam Rignol’s interpretation feels fluid enough, and I really like the sonority of her instrument, especially the melody voice. However, despite its sonic richness, the performance makes me feel like this Gavotte is challenging on a seven-string viola da gamba. I don’t mean to say that the artist is struggling, but the recording seems to suggest that the piece was not written with the viola da gamba in mind.
One little detail: Myriam Rignol is among a minority of artists who play the ornament on the first note in bar 20 as an appoggiatura (i.e., two crotchets with slightly different weight) rather than an acciaccatura. There is no slash through the small quaver note in Anna Magdalena Bach’s manuscript copy, so formally, it is indeed not an acciaccatura.
Gavotte II
The ritornello is slightly faster than the first Gavotte. It also feels lighter and more dance-like. The two couplets in the second part on the other hand are slightly slower and feel a little heavier.
In this interpretation, the structure of the second Gavotte differs from the common reading: the original structure is (AA)-(BACABACA), or |:A:||:BACA:|. Here, the segments are rearranged to (AA)-(BAACAA). This means that both ritornelli in the second part are repeated immediately, but the second part itself is not repeated. With this, couplets B (with the ostinato voice) and C (musette) are performed only once. While this is unfortunate, it is understandable, given that both couplets feel unwieldy on the viola da gamba. Unlike the Neue Bach-Ausgabe (Eppstein, 1988), the 17th-century sources do not explicitly include the two ritornello instances in the second part. Therefore, Myriam Rignol’s rearrangements are justified.
As if to compensate for the omission of the repetition of the two couplets, Rignol plays the da capo instance of the first Gavotte with both repeats. Two other artists also play the da capo with both repeats: David Watkin and Petr Skalka.
VII. Gigue (5’05”)
Doesn’t this mark the proverbial “last dance” not only for this Suite, but also for the entire set of six Cello Suites? As such, Myriam Rignol’s performance feels too tamed, formal, and static. The quaver triplets especially lack momentum and often feel stiff. The semiquaver segments, especially the virtuosic double-stop passages, save the interpretation. Also, the artist’s playing picks up momentum and gains intensity and temperament in the sonorous three- and four-string chords around climaxes.
Total Duration: 34’24”
Rating: 4 / 3 / 3.5 / 4.5 / 4 / 3.5 / 3.5 = 3.71
Comment: I like the sonority of the viola da gamba, and I enjoy Myriam Rignol’s playing in general. I also appreciate how careful she is with her articulation and how attentive she is to detail. However, in comparison with cello interpretations, Rignol’s performance often feels too restrained and subdued.
Petr Skalka, 2020
Claves, ℗/© 2023
Artist: Petr Skalka
Instrument: Five-string cello, op.224 by Dalibor Bzirský, Prague, 2018
gut strings, copy of a baroque bow, by Fausto Cangelosi, Florence
Pitch: a’ = 415 Hz
See the Comparison Summary for more information on artist, instrument, recording location etc.
For general comments concerning recording quality and settings, acoustics, as well as the artist’s approach to the Cello Suites see the posting on the Suite No.1 for Cello Solo in G major, BWV 1007.
I. Prélude (4’48”)
Petr Skalka offers one of the fastest Prélude performances in this comparison. His performance is the shortest among the modern and HIP cello recordings. In fact, it is faster than the timing suggests, considering the significant slowdown in the final bars. Skalka often also slows down at the climax of phrases. Nevertheless, there is very little, if any, space to breathe between phrases. Rather, he storms ahead from phrase to phrase, leaving the listener breathless.
His sonority is not particularly noisy or scratchy, but the artist leaves no doubt that he is playing on gut strings and using a baroque bow. The one noisy moment, though, is in the semiquaver cadenza, where he plays bars 85 and 86 with détaché articulation. This makes these bars sound unnecessarily scratchy.
II. Allemande (7’58”)
In the Allemande, Petr Skalka uses pronounced agogics to produce a gentle sway in large phrases. Despite the fluid tempo, which helps avoid lengths and drops in tension, the performance feels calm. The articulation is relatively light, yet the tone remains intense throughout. The sonority of Skalka’s instrument is neither particularly warm nor mellow. Rather, it has considerable “bite” and incisiveness, especially in the high register. Skalka does not try to conceal or avoid this quality.
Other noteworthy observations include the prominent, forceful, almost explosive deep C in bar 11. Bar 18 features a large jump from G (a dotted semiquaver) to f’, which involves skipping a string. Skalka fills this interval with an extra note. He may have done so to maintain momentum, or to avoid a gap when skipping a string. However, this ties two phrases together, despite Bach’s intention of a fresh start for the descent from f’. This extra note is rather unusual, to say the least. Finally, at the end of the second repeat, Skalka uses an extreme ritardando in bar 20.
III. Courante (3’32”)
The slurring in Anna Magdalena Bach’s manuscript copy of the Courante may be superficial and incomplete. However, this does not justify arbitrary articulation. In Petr Skalka’s interpretation, the quavers change from staccato (broad spiccato) to tenuto or quasi-legato, and the reasoning behind these choices is unclear. Additionally, many groups of slurred semiquavers, such as in bars 13 and 14 (six notes each), are played détaché, making them appear unnecessarily busy. Although there are agogics, the performance does not breathe or feel relaxed and free in any way.
IV. Sarabande (5’50”)
Petr Skalk’s interpretation of the Sarabande appears as a sincere “back to the basics” version with a good, fluid tempo and little vibrato, often none at all. Occasionally, the détaché crotchet bow strokes are a little too straight and flat, but in general, the performance feels calm and reflective.
My main concern is with the ornamentation. While I understand that artists want to express their personal view by adding embellishments, there is an unwritten rule that such ornamentation should be limited to repeats so that listeners can hear the original composition without additions. Petr Skalka adds ornamentation, but only to the repeat of the first part (bars 1 – 8) only. That seems like an odd decision. Why not for the second repeat? One could argue that Skalka’s deliberate and conscious articulation of the arpeggios makes them feel like simple ornaments. On the other hand, the first repeat is overloaded with added ornaments, which obscure the melodic and rhythmic structure.
V./VI. Gavotte I — Gavotte II — Gavotte I da capo (4’09”)
Gavotte I
Is the first Gavotte really supposed to sound so frugal? I really like performances with little or no vibrato, but here, many of the notes, whether détaché or slurred, sound rather raw, careless, and occasionally even tormented. The playing is generally not excessively noisy. However, upon “tearing off” three- or four-string chords, the artist seems to apply a lot of bow pressure near the frog, so the chords typically begin with a notable creaking sound. This contributes to the impression of a “raw” sonority.
Gavotte II
Along with David Watkin and Myriam Rignol, Petr Skalka is among a small group of artists performing the da capo instance of Gavotte I with both repeats. Is this superfluous, too much, or unwanted? Or is “more Bach” always better?
In the second Gavotte, the artist’s simple and natural articulation and tone fit the folksy character of the piece. Also, the two couplets feel perfectly integrated in tempo and style. One peculiarity about the performance is its structure. Bach’s original is structured (AA)-(BACABACA), or |:A:||:BACA:|, with “A” being the ritornello. Petr Skalka changed this to (AA)-(BABACCAA). In other words, the first part is repeated as written. Then, the artist split the second part further. The middle segment (ostinato couplet — ritornello) is repeated in itself. In the final segment (musette — ritornello), each of the two parts is repeated individually. It seems as if the artist wanted to minimize transitions into and out of the musette.
VII. Gigue (4’07”)
I don’t expect a historically informed performance to feel particularly smooth, let alone polished. Here, however, the interpretation often feels unpolished, raw, and even noisy. Sometimes there is an excess of “biting” articulation, e.g., in détaché semiquavers. The performance ranges from rhythmically strict to passages with grotesquely exaggerated agogics, e.g., at the beginning of the second part. With this, there is little persistent dance feeling.
Total Duration: 30’24”
Rating: 3.5 / 4 / 3.5 / 3.5 / 3.5 / 3.5 / 3.5 = 3.57
Comment: Petr Skalka offers a very outspoken and strong-minded, historically informed performance, with an articulation that often feels rough. I’m not sure how much of this is due to the recording setup. I also noted an occasional tendency toward quirkiness in articulation and agogics.
Lucile Boulanger, 2020— Viola da gamba (Partial)
Alpha Classics / Outhere Music France, ℗/© 2021
Artist: Lucile Boulanger (*1986, see also Wikipedia.fr)
Instrument: 7-string bass Viola da gamba by François Bodart, Andenne / Belgium, 2006, after an instrument by Joachim Tielke (1641 – 1719), Hamburg, 1699; bows by Craig Ryder and Luis Emilio Rodriguez Carrington
Pitch: a’ = 415 Hz
Recorded at Abbaye de Noirlac, Bruère-Allichamps, France (2020-12)
See the Comparison Summary for more information on artist, instrument, recording location etc.
For detailed media information and a detailed discussion of the complete contents of Lucile Boulanger’s CD set (2 CDs) see my separate media review from 2024-01-02.
I have briefly discussed the movements below in that posting and even compared them to the two complete viola da gamba interpretations that are part of this comparison (Paolo Pandolfo, Myriam Rignol). I don’t want to duplicate my remarks in that earlier posting. However, I though that tor the sake of completeness it might be interesting to include the essence of my findings for that movement from that earlier posting in a format that matches that of this comparison.
A Partial Recording Only
In her recording “Solo Bach-Abel”, gambist Lucile Boulanger did not include a complete cello suite. Rather, in an attempt to explore why Bach did not compose for solo viola da gamba, she put together a suite of her own, consisting of
- A viola da gamba arrangement of the Prelude in C major (here: D major) from Bach’s Prelude and Fuge in C major, BWV 846 (from “Das Wohltemperierte Clavier, Book I“
- Viola da gamba arrangements of the movements Allemande, Sarabande and Gavottes I/II from the Cello Suite No.6 in D major, BWV 1012
- A viola da gamba arrangement of the Courante from the Cello Suite No.3 in C major, BWV 1009, transposed to D major
- A Gigue in A major by Carl Friedrich Abel (1723 – 1787), transcribed by the artist “in the manner of J.S. Bach”
II. Allemande (8’38”)
Lucile Boulanger’s interpretation of the Allemande is notably faster than Myriam Rignol‘s. However, the tempo is still on the slow side, near the bottom of what I regard as workable. It is difficult for listeners to follow the harmonic progression across larger sections, let alone any large-scale melodic components in the top or accompanying voices. One could argue, though, that Bach himself obscured the large-scale developments by adding overly rich ornamentation to the melody. Lucile Boulanger can’t “fix” this, but her rhythmically liberal reading of the melody creates a steady, slow breath throughout the piece. Her beautiful ornamental garlands gently sway from one chord to the next, maintaining tension and flow throughout the movement.
Besides her flexible rhythmic approach, the artist adds a few extra ornaments, such as appoggiaturas and trills, to great effect. Lastly, the recording benefits from the rich sonority and internal resonances of the viola da gamba. It is a truly beautiful and harmonious recording.
IV. Sarabande (5’23”)
Judging Lucile Boulanger’s Sarabande in the context of this comparison, and in particular juxtaposing it to the other Sarabande performances may be a little unfair. This is not only because the movement is taken out of the context of a CD that explicitly does not present Bach’s Cello Suite as such, but also because the artist labels this as the result of her own transcription for the bass viol. This is similar to what Paolo Pandolfo does in his recording of the complete set of suites. Paradoxically, though, in this very movement, Pandolfo stays close to Bach’s original, while Lucile Boulanger’s transcription is much more personal, including many of her own ideas.
Lucile Boulanger’s Sarabande is certainly a beautiful piece of music for the viola da gamba, featuring full and rounded bass sonority. However, it should not be seen as competing with typical cello interpretations. In her adaptation for the seven-string bass viol, the artist altered many chords (e.g., by omitting, adding, or changing notes) and occasionally also added new chords and harmonies. In the repeats, she also adds a few extra ornaments.
The result is that, in terms of sonority, the voluptuous sound of Lucile Boulanger’s Sarabande outperforms many cello recordings. However, it represents less of Bach’s original writing, and its expression and narration pale in comparison to my favorite cello performances by artists such as Pieter Wispelwey and Anastasia Kobekina.
V./VI. Gavotte I — Gavotte II — Gavotte I da capo (4’05”)
Gavotte I
Lucile Boulanger’s interpretation of the first Gavotte has the same timing as Myriam Rignol’s recording. Unlike Rignol, however, Boulanger leaves the piece in its original key of D major. She also leaves Bach’s text largely unchanged. The few adjustments she makes to accommodate the viola da gamba pale in comparison to the instrument’s influence. The instrument obviously brings significant changes in sonority, response, and internal resonances.
Lucile Boulanger’s performance shines in her ability to make this technically challenging transcription sound like genuine music for the viola da gamba. Moreover, her performance feels effortless and natural throughout—it is simply beautiful dance music with rich agogics and full of Klangrede (Harnoncourt, 1983) The artist adds a number of ornaments. Seamlessly integrated, these ornaments feel genuine and inconspicuous while contributing to the overwhelming richness of the experience.
Gavotte II
The above remarks also apply to the second Gavotte, which is equally fascinating in Lucile Boulanger’s interpretation. Once again, the timing is nearly identical to Myriam Rignol‘s. However, Boulanger did not rearrange the structure of the movement the way Rignol did. She also omits the second repeat, though.
Once again, the performance feels like beautifully swaying dance music with light and effortless articulation and rich agogics. In the second part of the musette (bars 17 – 19), Boulanger replaces the quaver doublets with triplets, avoiding a repetition of the first musette part—an excellent idea.
Total Duration: 18’06” (partial recording only)
Rating: — / 4.5 / — / 4 / 5 / 5 / — = 4.53
Comment: Unfortunately, this is only a partial performance. It is part of a themed recording titled Bach & Abel. Performing all of Bach’s Cello Suites wasn’t the artist’s intent. While not comparable to cello interpretations, the performance, especially of the two Gavottes, is still a fascinating masterpiece and a highly recommended addition to the repertoire.
Bruno Philippe, 2021
Harmonia mundi, ℗ 2022
Artist: Bruno Philippe (*1993)
Instrument: Carlo Annibale Tononi (1675 – 1730), Venice; gut strings and baroque bow
See the Comparison Summary for more information on artist, instrument, recording location etc.
For general comments concerning recording quality and settings, acoustics, as well as the artist’s approach to the Cello Suites see the posting on the Suite No.1 for Cello Solo in G major, BWV 1007. Bruno Philippe’s cello is a standard, modernized four-string instrument, equipped with gut strings.
I. Prélude (4’45”)
Bruno Philippe’s performance is fluid, elegant, and light. He uses vibrant, elastic bowstrokes. In three-quaver motifs with a slur on the first two notes, the last (upstroke) note is often particularly springy, almost spiccato, with the bow leaving the string. The primary focus is on larger phrases and a harmonious flow rather than on detailed expression (Klangrede) at the level of individual motifs. Bach’s dynamics (echo bars) are subtle, often mere allusions.
The high positions (bars 69 ff.) don’t appear to be technically challenging, though one can sense the extra effort in accommodating these on a four-string instrument. Here, a five-string violoncello piccolo would offer extra lightness and better sonority. The high modern pitch (a’ = 440 Hz) accentuates this potential weakness. In the semiquaver cadenza, Bruno Philippe does not try to show virtuosity, but rather treats that segment with masterful and effortless diligence and clarity.
II. Allemande (8’11”)
In the Allemande, Bruno Philippe stays relatively close to the notation, which is too close for the chosen moderate tempo. I don’t think this interpretation exploits the true potential of the composition or the artist. More agogics and rhythmic freedom in the ornamentation would allow for additional Klangrede (Harnoncourt, 1983) and expression. Philippe also adds a few extra ornaments to the movement, predominantly in the repeats. I believe this is unnecessary, if not counterproductive in a movement that is already loaded with an abundance of explicit ornamentation.
One can tell that Philippe is playing a four-string instrument because some of the chords in the Allemande sound dull or muted. The instrument forces the artist to switch to high positions on all four strings, whereas on a five-string violoncello piccolo, several of the notes can be played on empty strings and in more comfortable lower positions. This results in much more resonance and fuller sonority. This is not a criticism of the artist, but a consequence of the chosen (and available) conditions.
III. Courante (3’20”)
One might call Bruno Philippe’s tempo extreme. It is faster than Steven Isserlis’ tempo and surpassed only by Vito Paternoster’s. However, the artist’s skills are astounding. The performance does not feel rushed, rather, it feels relaxed and effortless. It rarely loses momentum (and if so, it is hardly noticeable). The articulation is clean, though some of the fast passages may be difficult for listeners to follow. Dynamics and agogics contribute to a rich musical narration. Philippe even manages to insert a few playful trills and mordents in the repeats. All of this feels natural, nothing is forced or contrived. Congratulations on a masterful performance!
IV. Sarabande (4’31”)
Bruno Philippe’s performance of the Sarabande has the same timing as Jean-Guihen Queyras’ 2007 and 2023 recordings. Like Queyras’s performances, it has a natural tempo that makes the 3/2 meter palpable. It has the same acoustic clarity and transparency as Queyras’ first recording. Similar to Queyras’ 2023 performance, Philippe adds ornaments to the repeats. However, he limits these to a few, and they are all inconspicuous and natural. They fit seamlessly into the music. In comparison to Queyras’ interpretations, Bruno Philippe’s recording feels more introverted, unassuming, and almost modest. It is devoid of grand gestures and outbursts, and if there is vibrato, it is hardly noticeable. Introverted beauty!
V./VI. Gavotte I — Gavotte II — Gavotte I da capo (3’59”)
Gavotte I
Overall, I appreciate Bruno Philippe’s interpretation of the first Gavotte, especially his exquisite and well-placed ornaments in the repeats. However, I have reservations about the integration of the arpeggio chords into the musical flow, which does not feel entirely harmonious. One detail I find irritating is that quaver figures preceding chords tend to accelerate, as if to create space for the arpeggio that follows. There are even instances where such quavers are in danger of being swallowed. Perhaps the arpeggio chords take up too much time? They certainly also preclude any real dance swaying.
All artists face the challenge of playing the arpeggios without disrupting the rhythm. Anastasia Kobekina found an elegant solution. Rather than shortening quaver figures through uncontrolled acceleration, she uses jeu inégal, which feels deliberate, purposeful, and attractive at the same time.
Gavotte II
My main quibble about the second Gavotte is that the tempo is pushed throughout the movement. I don’t see why this movement should be that much faster than the first Gavotte. The feeling of being “rushed” persists even at the level of individual notes. The performance is expressive and very articulate throughout, but it lacks the swaying feel of a dance movement.
VII. Gigue (3’57”)
The interpretation of the Gigue is excellent, with a good, fluid tempo, clear and well-considered articulation and phrasing. There is a distinct dance-like quality, even though the fluid pace doesn’t leave ample space for agogics. I like the additional ornaments—mostly inverted mordents—that Bruno Philippe casually inserts. They fit well and are never intrusive or idiosyncratic. Philippe adds some to the first passes as well. The artist does not seem to encounter serious technical challenges in this often tricky movement, even though one can tell that the piece is anything but easy to play. Nevertheless, the performance conveys a dominant impression of joy and playfulness.
Total Duration: 28’44”
Rating: 4 / 4 / 4.5 / 4.5 / 4 / 4 / 4.5 = 4.21
Comment: This is an excellent recording by a young, emerging artist—somebody to watch out for! It is interesting, technically superb, and definitely recommended!

Pablo de Naverán, 2021
Claves, ℗/© 2023
Artist: Pablo de Naverán (*1975)
Instrument: Carlo Antonio Testore (1687 – 1765), Milan, 1723
See the Comparison Summary for more information on artist, instrument, recording location etc.
For general comments concerning recording quality and settings, acoustics, as well as the artist’s approach to the Cello Suites see the posting on the Suite No.1 for Cello Solo in G major, BWV 1007. Pablo de Naverán’s cello is a standard, modernized four-string instrument.
I. Prélude (4’55”)
For the majority of the movements in all of Bach’s cello suites, Pablo de Naverán tends towards slow tempi, often to the extreme. Here, however, he approaches the Prélude at a fluid pace, with momentum and elegance. He uses light articulation, focusing on phrases and arches rather than trying to differentiate at the level of quaver triplets. His agogics are very pronounced, occasionally even extreme, such as when the flow nearly stops in the middle of bar 82 (the opposite to David Watkin’s acceleration!). The semiquaver cadenza is very fast and virtuosic, but also feels slightly forced. Towards the end, however, he employs extreme slowdowns once more. This is a very lively interpretation, and one of the very best movements of this artist so far.
One minor reservation concerns the intonation: it isn’t inaccurate, but neither does it strike me as particularly pure, especially at high pitches. This may be due to the use of a regular four-string instrument, which forces the artist into very high positions on the fingerboard.
II. Allemande (10’25”)
The timing of Pablo de Naverán’s Allemande is nearly identical to that of Mstislav Rostropovich. Not surprisingly, de Naverán’s interpretation suffers from similar flaws. At least there isn’t Rostropovich’s prominent and ubiquitous vibrato, but again, the tempo is so slow that the underlying melodic and harmonic backbone is lost to the listener.
Pablo de Naverán somehow compounds the issue. While Rostropovich mechanically crawls through the explicit ornamentation, de Naverán uses very strong, if not extreme, agogics, which distort the flow of the semiquaver and shorter notes. This makes the performance less monotonous, yet it further obscures the distinction between the ornaments and the underlying structure of the composition. While Rostropovich’s interpretation is a constant crawl, de Naverán’s time often seems to stop within an extended ornamental figure. On rare occasions, one hears the artist grumble.
III. Courante (4’09”)
Unsurprisingly, the tempo is moderate; it is one of the slowest cello interpretations. However, the interpretation does not drag or feel sluggish, as the artist uses a capricious, springy spiccato articulation for most of the quavers.
There are a few instances of inconsequential articulation (slurring) in the quavers, but not nearly as prominently as in Marianne Dumas’ interpretation. However, the slurring in some of the semiquaver motifs (quadruplets) is ignored, which makes these appear unusually busy. To me, the highlighting of some musical gestures feels exaggerated. Also, some of the extended semiquaver segments feel slightly rushed. This may work in concert, but it has an adverse effect in a recording.
IV. Sarabande (5’04”)
Pablo de Naverán’s tempo is mid-range and unremarkable. It may occasionally be a little too fluid, but certainly not too slow in general. The articulation is broad and typically quasi-legato. The artist mostly observes the slurs in the score. The intonation seems technically correct, yet I often sense some unease, though the reasons are difficult to pinpoint. It feels as if the artist was using portamento in some transitions, or maybe just slow transitions between notes. I sense this particularly at transitions into and out of chords. Additionally, there are frequent segments with noticeable, nervous vibrato in a performance that often uses flat, vibrato-less tones. Overall, too many details distract from the beauty of the music.
V./VI. Gavotte I — Gavotte II — Gavotte I da capo (4’59”)
Gavotte I
This is one of the slowest interpretations of the first Gavotte. One might assume that this leaves ample time for articulation and phrasing. Oddly, however, the interpretation seems to demonstrate how clumsy and bulky a Gavotte can be. With its rigid alla breve pounding, the interpretation is reminiscent of Mstislav Rostropovich’s, though without the epically broad articulation. Rather, Pablo de Naverán uses a harsh, percussive staccato not just on chords and crotchets, but even on quavers. He splits most quaver quadruplets into doublets, which he plays with equally terse articulation. Moreover, many three- and four-string arpeggios are split into two segments, which occupy extra time, disrupt the rhythm, and disrupt any dance sway. Prominent examples can be found in the second part, in bars 8, 9, 16, and 17.
Gavotte II
The second Gavotte is much friendlier. The chords are gentler, and the first part (A, ritornello) feels restrained, if not a little cautious. The B segment in the second part, with the ostinato in the lower voice, adds a folksy, cozy note. The C segment (musette) is a little more fluid and ends with an intimate atmosphere. The second part ends with a “false” closure and a fermata. The hesitant return to the B segment in the repeat of the second part adds humorous note. The return of the musette and the last instance of the ritornello are even softer and more intimate than in the first pass.
VII. Gigue (4’48”)
Here’s an artist who took the term “dance sway” to the extreme! It starts with the first (and subsequent) upbeat quaver, which Pablo de Naverán launches like an arrow or a ballistic projectile. What follows is the most outrageous agogics I have ever encountered, both between bar lines and (even more so) within phrases. The agogics are supported by equally lively dynamics and articulation. If that isn’t the proverbial last dance, then I don’t know what is. Some might call this beyond reasonable limits. However, I can’t deny that I find the performance fascinating and enthralling. Is this the stroke of a genius or mere luck?
Total Duration: 34’20”
Rating: 4.5 / 2.5 / 4 / 3 / 2.5 / 4.5 / 5 = 3.71
Comment: Pablo de Naverán is an artist who likes to take risks. Often, he selects an extremely slow tempo or makes risky choices in articulation and phrasing. I don’t think his interpretations are driven by a mere urge to be different or stand out among the myriad of recordings. A desire to indulge in the rich sonority of his instrument may also have contributed. However, inevitably, not all listeners will appreciate such extremes, and some of his movements may be viewed as failures. But then again, his interpretations sometimes reveal fascinating facets bordering on genius, such as in the Gigue above.
Jean-Guihen Queyras, 2023
harmonia mundi, ℗ 2024
Artist: Jean-Guihen Queyras (*1967, see also Wikipedia)
Instrument: Gioffredo Cappa (1644 – 1717), Saluzzo, Italy, 1696
See the Comparison Summary for more information on artist, instrument, recording location etc.
For general comments on the artist’s approach to the Cello Suites see the posting on the Suite No.4 for Cello Solo in E♭ major, BWV 1010, or also the posting on the Suite No.1 for Cello Solo in G major, BWV 1007 (first recording, 2007). Jean-Guihen Queyras’ cello is a standard, modernized four-string instrument.
This 2023 recording was made in conjunction with the ballet project “Mitten wir im Leben sind / Bach6cellosuiten“ featuring Jean-Guihen Queyras performing most of Bach’s Cello Suites. See the Comparison Summary for a discussion of the included ballet performance on the accompanying Blu-ray disc, which was recorded in Belgium. The audio recording of the Suites, however, was done separately at the Vereenigde Doopsgezinde Gemeente in Haarlem, The Netherlands.
I. Prélude (4’38”)
Compared to his 2007 recording, Jean-Guihen Queyras opted for a slightly slower tempo, which is close to the overall average for this movement. He retained many features of his earlier interpretation. However, he made the new recording sound quite different with some interesting alterations, particularly in the articulation. One notable change is how he plays the bariolage motifs, where the tied notes are mere shadows of the preceding notes. This emphasizes the outer notes, highlighting the four beats of the 12/8 meter and the melody formed by the final note of these motifs. Overall, the dynamics at the level of motifs are more differentiated, giving extra focus to rhythm and hidden melodic components.
In this interpretation, exposing every detail in every motif becomes secondary. Instead, Queyras focuses on natural, organic phrasing. He accomplishes this primarily through detailed dynamics that go far beyond simple echo effects. Technically and musically, this is a performance at the highest level: effortless up to the highest positions, seamless and beautiful in its sonority across the range. The slightly slower, more relaxed pace opens opportunities for subtle agogics at the phrase level, making the performance less relentless and allowing for a natural buildup and release of tension across the big arches.
When the first big part comes to a close, the tension reaches its minimum. Before the music ascends to the tonal climax in the highest positions, the artist marks the turning point with an inconspicuous little ornament on the last two quavers in bar 61. The semiquaver cadenza rolls along with natural ease and virtuosity, building a final arch that ends in a subtle, soft conclusion. In the final bar, Queyras abandons the rhythm, playing the final quaver triplet as a simple, touching arpeggio figure.
II. Allemande (7’33”)
In this comparison, Jean-Guihen Queyras is represented by two recordings, alongside those of Anner Bylsma (from 1979 and 1992) and Pieter Wispelwey (from 1998 and 2012). Of these, his performances of the Allemande and Sarabande demonstrate the greatest consistency in the tempo selection. The timing of his 2023 performance of the Allemande is identical to that of his earlier 2007 recording. Unsurprisingly, also the basic interpretation has not changed dramatically either. The new recording uses slightly more pronounced agogics and even less vibrato. The linkage of the phrases to a single, continuous narrative is even more compelling. I have one minor, but negligible quibble about this performance: the occasional “belly note” and rare instances of Nachdrücken.
Unlike his 2007 recording, Queyras now consistently uses the “richer” version of bar 2, rather than the version from Anna Magdalena Bach’s manuscript copy (see above). In the repeats, the artist adds a few extra ornaments. Even though Bach’s rich, built-in ornamentation makes these seem unnecessary, they are natural, fitting and inconspicuous.
III. Courante (3’58”)
This is one of my favorite Courante interpretations, certainly among those using a regular four-string cello. The tempo feels fluid and natural, and the articulation is light and playful, devoid of obvious inconsistencies in the slurring. More than Anastasia Kobekina, Queyras plays in big arches: the first part forms a single, big phrase, while the second, longer part is slightly more structured. There is a distinct, dance-like sway. Without disrupting the flow, Queyras leaves space for strong accents on key notes. Examples can be found in the emphases on pivotal moments in bars 30/31 and 48/49. The long chains of semiquavers are all highly differentiated and full of life. Excellent!
IV. Sarabande (4’31”)
Jean-Guihen Queyras kept the timing of his second recording of the Sarabande exactly the same as in his 2007 performance. Not only did the tempo remain the same, but the basic interpretation did not change much, if at all. The sonority of the recording is slightly different, more intimate in the new recording. The main difference is that, unlike in his first recording, Queyras now adorns the repeats with numerous personal and inventive ornaments that feel fitting and natural. Nothing is overly extravagant or idiosyncratic—it’s simply excellent!
V./VI. Gavotte I — Gavotte II — Gavotte I da capo (3’54”)
Gavotte I
The contrast with Jean-Guihen Queyras’ 2007 recording of the Gavottes is striking. The 2023 performance is fluid and relaxed, at a “normal” tempo, leaving little, if anything, to be desired. The chords feel like a natural part of the musical flow, even when the artist broadens them at a climax. Additionally, the articulation and dynamics are detailed, and the agogics create a beautiful dance-like sway. In the last two bars of the first repeat, Queyras adds some nice little ornaments.
In the second part, Queyras gradually loosens his ties to the notation. This begins with the two chords in bar 12, which he breaks into ascending triplets in the first pass. In the repeat, he goes farther, changing quaver segments (bars 15, 18, and 19) into improvisational figures that loosely track the original notation. Finally, in bar 26, the descending quavers are capriciously changed into dotted motifs.
Gavotte II
The second Gavotte follows a similar pattern. Here, too, the tempo now meets the expectation. The first part (ritornello with repeat) and the couplets in the second part naturally follow the score, with careful and detailed articulation. Neither couplet exaggerates the folksy aspect of these segments. However, in bars 9, 11, and 21, Queyras splits the two voices into alternating quavers.
In the second repeat the ostinato couplet starts slowly and accelerates—just for fun or to hint at a caricature? In bars 9 and 11, the two voices change from crotchets to quaver triplets, similar to what Lucile Boulanger does in the musette. The musette itself is also changed into virtuosic quaver triplets, though in a more elaborate scheme. Only the final ritornello remains unchanged, “restoring order”, so to speak.
Finally, the da capo instance of the first Gavotte is played without repeats and remains largely unadorned, as written.
My main quibble with this interpretation is that the artist’s fun alterations, especially in the second Gavotte, go too far, altering the character of the piece. Additionally, some of the “tricks”, such as breaking notes into fast triplets, seem overused, if not idiosyncratic, in such a short piece. Shouldn’t they rather feel spontaneous?
VII. Gigue (4’19”)
Compared to his first recording of the Gigue in 2007, Jean-Guihen Queyras’ tempo is now noticeably more moderate. Unfortunately, I’m not entirely happy with this movement. While the flow is generally smooth and fluent, the articulation is often oddly “fluffy” and too gentle for a Gigue, especially the final dance in all of the Cello Suites. Examples are the dissonant chords and quaver triplets in bars 21 and 22, as well as many of the détaché quaver segments. Other passages lack rhythmic contours, such as the quaver segment in bars 5 – 8. Only in the repeat of the second part, beginning around bar 51, does the artist appear to hold a firmer grip, setting a characterful, “outspoken” end point to his interpretation.
In the repeat, the added ornamentation in bars 18 and 19 feels overdone and barely fits the character of the piece. Also, Queyras occasionally broadens motifs or inserts very brief, reflective pauses, such as after the dotted crotchet in bar 54, which disrupts the flow and prevents persistent dance swaying.
Total Duration: 28’54”
Rating: 5 / 5 / 5 / 5 / 5 / 4.5 / 4 = 4.79
Comment: Up to and including the first Gavotte, I really like this recording of the D major Suite—it meets my expectations. However, I’m slightly disappointed by the second Gavotte and the Gigue.

Anastasia Kobekina, 2025
Sony Classical, ℗/© 2025
Artist: Anastasia Kobekina (*1994, see also Wikipedia)
Instrument: Five-string violoncello piccolo from Mittenwald, gut strings and baroque bow
Pitch: a’ = 415 Hz
See the Comparison Summary for more information on artist, instrument, recording location etc.
For general comments concerning recording quality and settings, acoustics, as well as the artist’s approach to the Cello Suites see the posting on the Suite No.1 for Cello Solo in G major, BWV 1007. For additional comments see my review of Anastasia Kobekina’s solo recital in Zurich on 2021-04-25.
I. Prélude (4’58”)
In my listening sequence, from slower to faster performances, Anastasia Kobekina’s Prélude follows right after Marianne Dumas’ interpretation. The timing is almost identical, but the outcome of these two historically informed performances could hardly be more different. Marianne Dumas uses broad, quasi-legato articulation and presents an incessant stream of quaver triplets. In contrast, Anastasia Kobekina brings every motif and phrase to life with rich agogics, light and differentiated articulation, and lively dynamics.
Anastasia Kobekina’s bariolage motifs often appear with almost percussive articulation, with the slurs and ties taken as ordering/associating indicators rather than legato notation. Rather than forcing a constant stream of quaver triplets, the artist clearly separates phrases with deliberate gaps and uses distinct broadening of key notes in order to achieve Klangrede (Harnoncourt, 1983). Indeed, her interpretation is a true role model in the application of Klangrede.
I concede that lovers of traditional interpretations may find Anastasia Kobekina’s agogics (and dynamics) extreme, if not exaggerated. I find them enthralling, not least because the artist embodies her interpretation! Despite the rich agogics, her articulation retains clarity and definition without ever seeking polished perfection in sonority. The virtuosic semiquaver “cadenza” is masterful in its clarity, diligence, and elegance, devoid of superficiality or showy effects, leading to the intimate, subtle ending. Beautiful!
II. Allemande (8’14”)
The magic of Anastasia Kobekina’s performance continues in the Allemande—a marvelous interpretation! Like Thomas Demenga, she treats the notation in Bach’s ornamentation rhythmically freely, as a guideline, not as exact prescription—after all, it is indeed ornamentation. Like Demenga, her melody line tells stories in every phrase. Here, though, the phrases tend to be longer. I don’t hear a dialog (as with Demenga), but an intense, rich narration.
It feels as if the artist is offering a spontaneous interpretation, not premeditated, but living in the moment. She offers an intimate performance, in which every phrase is an immensely rich reflection. The calmness of her interpretation is striking: there are no grand gestures, just gentle swaying. Nothing is rushed. The repeats feel slightly more expressive. Apart from rhythmic freedom, Anastasia Kobekina keeps the text as is. Her only additions are minimal, such as an appoggiatura or an inverted mordent, which suit the flow of her melody.
III. Courante (4’03”)
The Courante is not without technical challenges. However, it is not intended to showcase virtuosity. Rather, it is primarily meant to be a joyful Baroque dance movement. Anastasia Kobekina’s performance exemplifies this perfectly. Her approach is natural, relaxed, and unpretentious. Without aiming for polished perfection, her interpretation breathes in broad arches through lively dynamics and agogics. Even though the artist does not dissect the movement down to tiny motifs, every phrase contributes to and is embedded in the dramatic flow. Marvelous!
IV. Sarabande (5’30”)
In view of Pieter Wispelwey’s two interpretations (1998 and 2012), I would describe the tempo of Anastasia Kobekina’s performance as moderate, but not slow. However, her interpretation shares the intimacy and warmth of Wispelwey’s performances. It is gentler and lighter, though, as the artist discharges every motif and note. Additionally, her agogics and subtle jeu inégal breathe life into even the smallest musical figure. At the end of the first part, a lovely ascending ornament leads back to the beginning. This is not the foreboding of an ornamented repeat, though; the solemnity of the music appears to forbid heavy ornamentation. The alterations in the repeat are inconspicuous: one added turn, one appoggiatura, and subtle changes in the jeu inégal.
Given the subtlety of Anastasia Kobekina’s performance, is this still a lament? Where is the intensity? The answer is yes, it absolutely is, just introverted, not the intense, if not loud, whining in some traditional interpretations. Isn’t silent mourning, whispered complaints, and tears exactly what makes bystanders turn toward the affected person—the grieving victim? In the second part, the climax is short (just bars 23 – 27) and stays in a sphere of intimacy. In bars 16 and 28, the flow pauses on the dotted half-note chord before hesitantly resuming. Often, the bow barely touches the strings. In all its intimacy and subtlety, the emotional intensity of this interpretation is unmatched.
V./VI. Gavotte I — Gavotte II — Gavotte I da capo (4’14”)
Gavotte I
Like the other artists, Anastasia Kobekina faced the challenge of incorporating the three- and four-string arpeggios into the musical flow. In many performances, this issue disrupts the rhythm or makes the performance feel clumsy. Bruno Philippe avoided that by shortening quaver figures through uncontrolled acceleration.
Anastasia Kobekina elegantly and effectively solved this problem by using jeu inégal, which sounds deliberate, purposeful, and attractive. The jeu inégal forms an integral part of the artist’s lively agogics, resulting in a pronounced, joyful dance sway. It is truly a masterful performance, and an experience to behold!
Gavotte II
The arpeggio chords in the ritornello are not an issue. They serve as launching points for the subsequent two-bar phrase. With its simple, two-part structure, the six instances of the ritornello (including repeats) also serve as the organizing framework for the movement.
Anastasia Kobekina structurally separates the two couplets from the ritornelli by using short fermatas. With their slower beginning and gentle acceleration, the two couplets add a folksy note. Unfortunately, the couplets are short, but fortunately, they return in the repeat. The “ostinato” couplet feels particularly short, though it is carefully crafted as a short peasant dance. The musette (second couplet) is absolutely lovely with its warmth and the pronounced agogics. Beyond joy, there is even a pinch of humor and fun, especially in the final repeat!
VII. Gigue (4’38”)
Playing at a tempo similar to Pablo de Naverán’s, Anastasia Kobekina makes the most of the moderate tempo, bringing melody lines to life with pronounced jeu inégal. She adds her own lively agogics to every bar and motif. Her performance is impulsive, light, playful and fun, with rich, detailed dynamics. She doesn’t venture nearly as far into extremes as Pablo de Naverán, though. There are moments when she uses the bass string sonority and strong agogics to create a decidedly rustic atmosphere—as if she had saved the rustic character that many artists deploy in the Gavottes for the final movement, making that a true last dance. It’s all highly fascinating and enthralling.
Total Duration: 31’37”
Rating: 5 / 5 / 5 / 5 / 5 / 5 / 5 = 5.00
Comment: The beauty of Anastasia Kobekina’s interpretation lies not only in her masterful playing, but also in the fact that it comes straight from her heart and reflects her youthful, spontaneous, and open-minded personality. Throughout the recording her performance is an absolute joy to listen to. It deserves my strongest possible recommendation!
Conclusions
The table above should be self-explanatory, especially in combination with the detailed comments for each of the recordings. Keep in mind that the ratings reflect my own opinion. I have stated that I prefer historically informed performances. To some degree, this has of course influenced the results above. More so, my aversion against strong vibrato has had its effect on my ratings. And, of course, my preference has “not helped” the rating of traditional performances.
Please take the numeric ratings with a grain of salt. Small differences in the last digits are not relevant, and I never aimed to create a “definitive” ranking list. At best, one may compare the results of similar performances, such as HIP recordings, traditional or non-HIP performances, historical “landmark” recordings, and the like.
If you think you already have the cello recording(s) you like the most: why not expand and enrich your experience? Why not venture listening into performances on one of the above alternative instruments?
Other Review Posts on J.S. Bach’s Cello Suites, BWV 1007 – 1012
- The 6 Suites for Cello Solo — Comparison Summary
- Suite No.1 for Cello Solo in G major, BWV 1007
- Suite No.2 for Cello Solo in D minor, BWV 1008
- Suite No.3 for Cello Solo in C major, BWV 1009
- Suite No.4 for Cello Solo in E♭ major, BWV 1010
- Suite No.5 for Cello Solo in C minor, BWV 1011
- Suite No.6 for Cello Solo in D major, BWV 1012 — This review
Acknowledgements
The author would like to express his gratitude to:
- Myriam Rignol for her help by clarifying the author’s open questions about her recording (i.e., its documentation).
- Claves records for the pre-release copy of Pablo de Naverán’s 2021 recording, as well as for Petr Skalka’s 2020 pre-release CD set. I’m grateful for their patience with me—I have not (yet) reviewed so many of the CDs that they keep sending to my address.
Literature References
- Eppstein, H. (1988). Sechs Suiten für Violoncello Solo, Text I (nach den Abschriften Anna Magdalena Bachs und Johann Peter Kellners) (Neue Bach-Ausgabe, Urtext Edition, Serie VI, Vol. 2). Bärenreiter Verlag.
- Harnoncourt, N. (1983). Musik als Klangrede : Wege zu einem neuen Musikverständnis : Essays und Vorträge. Residenz Verlag, Salzburg. ISBN 978-3-7017-0315-9.























































